Applicant v. Western Assurance (17-005066)

The insurer raised two preliminary issues in advance of a hearing. The first issue was whether the claimant was prevented from appealing the insurer’s refusal to pay a number of claims because she failed to commence her appeal within two years of the date her claims for benefits was denied. Adjudicator Ferguson held that the claimant was prevented from appealing one claim but that the remaining four at issue could proceed. The parties agreed that the claimant’s appeal was filed more than two years after the dates that the insurer notified her of its refusal to pay the disputed benefits; however all but one of the denials failed to provide the claimant clear and unequivocal notice that it denied her claims and why. The second issue was whether the claimant was prevented from appealing two specific claims because she failed to submit those claims to the insurer within the time limits prescribed by the Schedule. Adjudicator Ferguson held that the claimant was prevented from appealing both denials at issue. Adjudicator Ferguson rejected the claimant’s explanations for failing to comply with the s. 32 timelines for making claims for lack of credibility.

Applicant v. Royal and Sun Alliance (17-003732)

The minor claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, and four treatment plans. The insurer argued that the claim for NEBs was time barred, and that the claimant’s injuries fell within the MIG. Adjudicator Hines held that the two year limitation period did not apply to the minor claimant until she hit the age of majority. She also held that the claimant’s mother was not deemed a litigation guardian by virtue of filling out SABS forms for the claimant. In terms of NEB entitlement, Adjudicator Hines held that the claimant failed to prove a substantial change in her life following the accident, and raised concerns about many inconsistencies in the claimant’s reporting. In terms of the medical benefits, Adjudicator Hines concluded that the claimant’s injuries were minor in nature, and that the treatment plans were therefore not payable.

K.G. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (16-003633)

The insurer argued that the claimant failed to apply to the LAT within two years of the refusal to pay in accordance with section 56 of the SABS. The claimant argued the insurer’s explanation of benefits (EOB) did not constitute a denial in compliance with the SABS. Adjudicator Watt held the EOB did not constitute a denial and that the claimant could proceed with her claim. There was no evidence that the insurer provided the claimant the information and forms required in response to her application for benefits. Stating in the EOB that the claimant “did not qualify” for a benefit does not amount to refusing to pay a benefit that has been claimed.

W.C.C. v. Allstate Canada (17-001363)

The claimant sought entitlement to non-earner benefits, which had been denied by the respondent on May 22, 2013, and entitlement to two treatment plans. Adjudicator Daoud dismissed all the claims, finding that the claimant was limitation barred from disputing the denial of non-earner benefits and that the claimant had not proven that the disputed treatment plans were reasonable and necessary. The claimant argued that the two-year limitation period should be extended or should not apply for a number reasons, which were all rejected by Adjudicator Daoud. Adjudicator Daoud held that (a) an insurer’s denial of a benefit, even if it is legally incorrect, will trigger the two-year limitation clock; (b) the 26-week waiting period for NEBs is not in reference to entitlement but to when NEBs are payable; and (c) a benefit that is prematurely denied by an insurer may still be considered proper and trigger the two-year limitation period.

K.G. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (16-003633)

The insurer argued that the claimant failed to apply to the LAT within two years of the refusal to pay in accordance with section 56 of the SABS. The claimant argued the insurer’s explanation of benefits (EOB) did not constitute a denial in compliance with the SABS. Adjudicator Watt held the EOB did not constitute a denial and that the claimant could proceed with her claim. There was no evidence that the insurer provided the claimant the information and forms required in response to her application for benefits. Stating in the EOB that the claimant “did not qualify” for a benefit does not amount to refusing to pay a benefit that has been claimed.

M.T.G. v. Aviva General Insurance (formerly RBC General Insurance) (17-002122)

The insurer requested the preliminary hearing to address whether the claimant was limitation barred from pursuing a claim for IRBs because the LAT application was not commenced within two years of the insurer’s denial. Adjudicator Gottfried held that the claimant was not precluded from applying for IRBs. The limitations analysis involved a lengthy review of correspondence between Aviva, the claimant, and the claimant’s lawyer regarding IRB stoppage. The limitation decision rested on which letter from the insurer started the limitation clock. The claimant and his lawyer both denied receiving a letter from Aviva regarding IRB stoppage dated February 11 2015. Aviva claimed that this letter was sent to the claimant by regular mail and copied to the claimant’s lawyer. Adjudicator Gottfried accepted the affidavit evidence of the claimant and his lawyer that it was not received. Adjudicator Gottfried found that the date of discoverability of the denial was August 17, 2015, which is the date of a follow-up letter from Aviva to the claimant’s lawyer regarding IRB payments and stoppage. Aviva argued that even if the claimant’s lawyer had not received a copy of the original stoppage letter in February 2015, a copy of that letter was included in the complete AB file materials provided to the claimant’s lawyer on March 23, 2015. Adjudicator Gottfried’s analysis did not clearly state why this date was not accepted, though the evidence suggested that the claimant’s lawyer did not review the AB file materials.

D.A. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (16-001381)

This is a preliminary issue decision on whether the claimant was statute barred from pursuing a claim for non-earner benefits because the LAT application was filed more than two years after the benefit was denied. This matter involved the transition from FSCO to the LAT. Adjudicator Ferguson found that the LAT application had been filed within 90 days of the FSCO mediator’s report and, accordingly, the claim for non-earner benefits was not statute barred. Of note, Arbitrator Ferguson also commented on the LAT’s discretion to extend limitation periods under section 7 of the Licence Appeal Tribunal Act. Arbitrator Ferguson held that there are four factors for determining whether an extension of a limitation period should be granted: i. the existence of a bona fide intention to appeal within the appeal period;  ii. the length of the delay; iii. prejudice to either party; and iv. the merits of the appeal. Arbitrator Ferguson found that it was not necessary to invoke section 7 in this matter, but he noted that the claim for non-earner benefits met the criteria for granting an extension to the limitation period.

Applicant v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (16-002633)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and two medical benefits. The insurer argued that the claim was time barred. Adjudicator Maedel held that the claimant had applied to the LAT within 90 days of receipt of the FSCO Report of Mediator, and was therefore within the limitation period. He concluded that the claimant’s injuries were minor in nature and that the claimant’s evidence did not support removal from the MIG.

S.R. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-004556)

The insurer argued that the claimant was barred from seeking IRBs due to the limitation period. It had denied IRBs when the claimant returned to work. The denial letter stated that if the claimant was off work again due to injuries, the insurer would require an updated Disability Certificate. Adjudicator Ferguson held that the denial was not clear and unequivocal because it appeared that the claimant remained entitled to IRBs if she had to leave work due to her injuries. The claim for IRBs was allowed to proceed.

Applicant v. Unifund (17-000982)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, removal from the MIG, and further medical benefits. The insurer argued that the claimant was barred from seeking NEBs due to the limitation period. Adjudicator Harmison accepted that the insurer had denied NEBs more than five years prior, and that the denial was clear and unequivocal. In terms of the medical benefits claim, the adjudicator held that the claimant failed to prove that his injuries were outside of the MIG. The adjudicator placed significant weight on the records from the family physician, which showed only one entry referring to the accident, and no reports of psychological injury.