D.M. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-008708)

The claimant sought entitlement to a treatment plan for physiotherapy. Adjudicator Grant held that the treatment plan was not reasonable and necessary. The claimant’s evidence did not show that physiotherapy was anticipated to provide any benefit. Further, the claimant stated to IE assessors that physiotherapy was not providing long-term benefit.

H.S.H. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-002204)

The claimant sought entitlement to two medical benefits, and a series of catastrophic impairment assessments. Adjudicator Reilly rejected all of the claims. She held that the proposed benefits were not reasonable and necessary. The medical records from the family physician shows no ongoing accident-related impairments.

S.A. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-006278)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of part of a chronic pain program, a bone growth stimulator, and an MRI. Adjudicator Lake dismissed the reconsideration. She held that the claimant failed to prove that the Tribunal made an error of law or fact. In essence, the claimant was seeking a re-weighing of the evidence, which was not the purpose of a reconsideration.

P.M. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-005419)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and medical benefits. She also sought entitlement to an accounting report. Adjudicator Watt denied the claim for IRBs, as the claimant had been paid IRBs up to the date she returned to work on a modified basis. He found the treatment plans not reasonable and necessary. Finally, he held that the cost of the accounting report was not payable because it was the claimant’s behaviour which resulted in difficulties calculating the IRB. She withheld information regarding disability benefits and her return to work. Furthermore, she was not a self-employed person.

Fordjour v. Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada (2019 ONSC 6268)

The claimant judicial review of the dismissal of her claim on two grounds: that she her family physician should be entitled to give opinion evidence, and that the adjudicator did not properly address causation. The Divisional Court agreed with the claimant and remitted the matter for a new hearing. It held that the Tribunal erred in not permitting the family physician to give opinion evidence at the hearing. The Divisional Court also wrote that the Tribunal had not set out the causation test it had applied, and that it was no appropriate for the test to be “implied.”

A.M.F. v. The Dominion of Canada General Insurance Company (17-006710)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision that the claimant suffered a catastrophic impairment and that she was entitled to two medical benefits for physical therapy. Adjudicator Parish rejected the reconsideration. She found that all of the insurer’s arguments essentially amounted to re-argument of the case. The Tribunal was not required to make note of every finding of every expert in its decision, nor was it required to address all case law submitted by the parties. The Tribunal’s decision to accept the opinion of the claimant’s assessors over the insurer’s assessors was not an error of law. Nor was use of the California Method for converting a GAF into WPI.

P.G. v. Intact Insurance Company (18-005386)

The claimant sought entitlement to ongoing IRBs and over $20,000 in assessments related to the IRB claim. Adjudicator Parish held that the claimant was entitled to IRBs up to the 104-week mark, but that the claimant’s functionality did not meet the “complete inability” test. She also awarded the cost of an occupational therapy situational assessment, orthopaedic assessment, and vocational assessment because they were relevant to the claimant’s injuries and claim for IRBs. The proposed psychological assessment, neurological assessment, executive summary, and transportation were not awarded because the claimant had not sought or been referred for psychological or neurological treatment; the executive summary was duplicative of the awarded assessments; and there was no evidence that transportation to the assessments was required.

R.F. v. Unifund Assurance Company (18-007571)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to two medical benefits for further physiotherapy. Adjudicator Mazerolle concluded that the claimant suffered a psychological impairment as a result of the accident, and was not restricted by the MIG limits. He awarded the two claimed medical benefits, writing that such treatment was promoting the claimant’s recovery.

D.K. v. Aviva General Insurance (18-007372)

The claimant sought entitlement to two medical benefits for further chiropractic treatment. Adjudicator Norris awarded the first treatment plan, holding that the treatment was providing the claimant with functional improvement at that time. The second treatment plan was denied. By that time, the claimant had returned to work on a full time basis and there was a lack of evidence of the need for any further passive therapy.

B.D.W. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-006313)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s award of one medical benefit. Adjudicator Parish rejected the reconsideration, writing that the Tribunal’s decision was based on a weighing of the evidence and the varying opinions of the experts. There was nothing in the decision suggesting that the Tribunal acted outside its jurisdiction or violated the rules of fairness.