Applicant v. Coachman Insurance Company (16-003306)

The claimant sought entitlement to removal from the MIG, IRBs, ACBs, medical benefits, and special award. He argued that he sustained a fractured sternum, a concussion, and major depressive disorder as a result of the accident. Despite an IE assessor concluding that the fractured sternum was related to the accident, the insurer concluded otherwise based on the related CT scan being performed a month after the accident in a foreign country. Adjudicator Gosio concluded that the claimant did suffer a fractured sternum, a concussion, and psychological impairments from the accident. He removed the claimant from the MIG and awarded some of the claimed medical benefits. He awarded IRBs based on the claimant being unable to perform his employment as a realtor primarily due to psychological issues. Surveillance of the claimant being physically functional did not persuade Adjudicator Gosio that the claimant was untruthful or that he was able to return to his employment. Adjudicator Gosio also awarded fifteen months of ACBs and held that the insurer had unreasonably withheld payment. Services were deemed incurred in accordance with section 3(8). Finally, Adjudicator Gosio issued a special award against the insurer in relation to ACBs due to the manner in which it denied ACBs and mislead the claimant on the IE physician’s opinion.