LAT Case Law Summaries

Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP is pleased to provide this online resource to our clients. Below is a searchable database of the publicly released decisions from the Licence Appeal Tribunal. Assembled by the accident benefits group, the decisions are reviewed, briefly summarized, and categorized for easy access.

As of March 2020, we will not include any further decisions focused solely on the Minor Injury Guideline or treatment plans, unless the case may have broader applicability.

Search

Generic filters

September 11, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Joaquim v. Intact Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 5120)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that she was failed to attend an IE in relation to a claimed prescription expense. The claimant argued that the SABS does not permit an IE in relation to prescriptions. The Divisional Court granted the appeal, holding that only items required to be submitted on a treatment plan could...

August 2, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Kellerman-Bernard v. Unica Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 4423)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that she could not receive a catastrophic impairment designation because she was not involved in the subject accident. The claimant's son was significantly injured in an accident, and the claimant suffered psychological injuries. The Tribunal held that only persons involved in an accident could apply for a catastrophic impairment...

July 25, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Abdi v. TD General Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 3536)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that he did not suffer a catastrophic impairment, as he did not meet the Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale ("GOS-E"). In particular, the adjudicator preferred the assessments of the insurer which took place almost 24 months after the accident, rather than the assessments of the claimant which took place around...

June 30, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Luluquisin v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (2023 ONSC 3912)

The claimant sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision regarding the quantum of ACBs awarded, and entitlement to various medical benefits. The insurer argued that the decision should have been appealed, rather than the subject of judicial review. The Court agreed with the insurer, holding that judicial review was not warranted and that the Court...

June 20, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Khan v. Allstate Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 3652)

The claimant appealed the LAT's decision that he did not suffer a catastrophic impairment. The claimant argued that procedural fairness was denied because he did not know the insurer would argue that an intervening event was the cause of his impairments, and argued that the LAT applied the wrong causation test. The LAT dismissed the...

June 15, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Kahissay v. Intact Insurance (2023 ONSC 3650)

Two claimants sought judicial review of the Tribunal Orders staying their applications while ordering the claimants to attend IEs prior to hearings on catastrophic impairment disputes. The Court held that the judicial review was premature and should not be heard. The cases did not raise exceptional circumstances, absent which the Court would not consider review...

June 7, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Soldatovas v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 3440)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's denial of IRBs and a special award, arguing that the decision lacked procedural fairness, reasonableness, and did not consider key evidence. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the Tribunal provided the claimant with an opportunity to present his case, and holding that the Tribunal was not required to cite...

June 7, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Aviva Insurance Canada v. Harland-Bettany (2023 ONSC 3395)

The insurer appealed the Tribunal's decision that the claimant's slip and fall on ice met the definition of accident. The claimant's application included other disputes relating to accident benefits claims that were not yet decided. The Court held that the insurer's appeal was premature as the accident definition decision was interlocutory. The Court wrote that...

May 26, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Pinera v. Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund (2023 ONSC 3155)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that he was not involved in an accident. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the Tribunal's reasons had no error of law, and that the claimant's appeal was largely an attempt to relitigate the factual issues that were before the adjudicator.

May 1, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Bennett v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada (2023 ONSC 2609)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's denial of a special award related to IRBs which were reinstated after the post-104 week mark following further medical assessments. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that it did not raise an issue of law. The Tribunal's determination regarding the special award were factual in nature, and the Tribunal applied...

April 28, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Nguyen v. Economical Mutual Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 2541)

The claimant appealed the LAT's decision that the limitation period barred the application. The Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for a new hearing. The Court found the Tribunal erred in concluding that the denial letter was received on the day it was authored, as no evidence was before the...

April 28, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Sahadeo v. Pafco Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 2542)

The claimant appealed the LAT's dismissal of his catastrophic impairment dispute, arguing that the Tribunal's supplemental reasons contained in the reconsideration decision violated the principles of fairness. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the SPPA gave the Tribunal the power to make rules to reconsider its own decision, and that the reconsideration process gave...

April 26, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Di Giulio v. Aviva General Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 2426)

The claimant sought a stay from Divisional Court of the LAT's decision that the dispute would proceed in writing rather than orally. The Court rejected the stay, holding that there was not a serious issue, there was no irreparable harm if the stay was not granted, and the balance of convenience did not favour the...

April 18, 2023

/

tgp-admin

TD General Insurance Company v. Duff-Foley (Estate) (2023 ONSC 2400)

The insurer appealed the Tribunal's decision that the settlement between the insurer was valid and enforceable. The claimant died 10 days after settling her tort and AB claims for $957,000, with 60 percent to be structured. The 60 percent was returned to the insurer based on the reversion; however, the claimant's estate took the position...

March 14, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Tamayo v. Licence Appeal Tribunal (2023 ONSC 1692)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision denying an adjournment of a scheduled hearing. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the denial of the adjournment was an interlocutory step from which no appeal was permitted. The Court also declined to grant a stay of the proceedings.

March 13, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Lengyel v. The Licence Appeal Tribunal (2023 ONSC 1623)

The claimant appealed and sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision to dismiss her application due to non-attendance at an IE. The Court dismissed the appeal and judicial review, holding that the Tribunal properly considered the SABS and the materials before it, and the result was a reasonable outcome available to the Tribunal under the...

March 6, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Hutchinson v. Aviva General Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 1472)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that she was not entitled to various medical benefits. The claimant argued that the Tribunal's refusal to convert the videoconference hearing to a written hearing was a breach of procedural fairness and natural justice. The claimant's counsel had argued that the claimant was unable to participate in the hearing...

February 23, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Amadiegwu v. Aviva General Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 1256)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision dismissing her claim for IRBs. The Court dismissed the appeal holding that there was no extricable question of law. The Court also rejected the arguments that the Tribunal process lacked procedural fairness or that the Tribunal did not apply the correct test for causation.

February 6, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Varriano v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada (2023 ONCA 78)

The insurer appealed the Divisional Court's decision that the limitation period on IRBs did not commence because the denial did not provide any medical reasons. The insurer argued that the only basis for denial was the claimant's return to work (i.e. an "other" reason), and that it was not required to state a medical reason...

January 31, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Waterloo Insurance v. Switzer (2023 ONSC 604)

The insurer appealed the Tribunal's decision regarding the calculation of a self-employed person's IRB where the person was self-employed for less than one year. The Tribunal allowed the claimant to use income earned from his previous employer, despite not being employed at the time of the accident and not being employed in the six months...

January 3, 2023

/

tgp-admin

Madore v. Intact Insurance Company (2023 ONSC 11)

The claimant appealed the Tribunal's decision that he was not involved in an "accident" as defined in the SABS. The claimant had been inspecting and cleaning the roof of his camper trailer, which was hitched to his pickup truck. In the course of cleaning the trailer, the claimant fell to the ground, suffering serious injuries...

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1850

smilne@tgplawyers.com

© 2020 Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Statement of Principles

Powered by Crow & Pitcher

Subscribe to get TGP’s case summaries straight to your inbox

Subscribe to get TGP’s case summaries straight to your inbox

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1850

smilne@tgplawyers.com

© 2020 Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP