Montesano v. Western Assurance Company (19-006780)

The claimant was smoking a cigarette on her driveway as she was walking towards her house and tripped and fell forward striking her face against the rear bumper of her SUV before falling on the ground. The insurer argued that the claimant was not involved in an “accident”. Adjudicator Boyce dismissed the insurer’s motion found that the claimant was involved in an accident. Adjudicator Boyce held that the claimant met both the purpose and causation tests. With respect to the purpose test, there is no requirement that the vehicle in question be in active use. A parked vehicle falls within the ordinary scope of use and operation. Adjudicator Boyce also agreed that the accident met the causation test: but for the vehicle being parked in the driveway, the claimant would not have struck her face against the bumper and fallen to the ground. The dominant feature of the incident was the claimant striking her face against the bumper. The insurer argued that the condition of the driveway caused the claimant’s fall. Adjudicator Boyce held that this was speculative and noted that at her examination under oath, the claimant denied tripping on a protruding water pipe and found her evidence regarding the facts of loss to be credible.

Madore v. Intact Insurance Company (20-000703)

The claimant was on the roof of his trailer checking the roof in preparation for a road trip when he fell off the roof and suffered significant injuries. The insurer brought a motion arguing that the claimant was not involved in an accident. Adjudicator Grant agreed with the insurer. Adjudicator Grant accepted that the incident arose out of the ordinary and well-known activities of the trailer, being a pre-travel inspection. However, Adjudicator Grant found that the incident did not meet the causation test. Adjudicator Grant agreed with the insurer that the claimant suffered injuries because he fell off the roof of his trailer. The incident did not involve the use or operation of the trailer and there was an intervening cause, being that the claimant lost his footing while standing on the roof of the trailer.

Amiri and Mireskandari v. The Co-operators (20-003296 & 20-003319)

The claimants made a claim for accident benefits following an incident in which they witnessed a vehicle strike a close family member (spouse and father-in-law, respectively). The incident was only a few feet in front of the claimant. The claimants heard the collision and witnessed the aftermath. The claimant alleged that they suffered psychological injuries. Because neither claimant had their own automobile insurance, they made a claim to the policy of the driver who struck the relative. Adjudicator Norris concluded that neither of the claimants were an “insured person” because they were not “a person who is involved in the accident involving the insured automobile”. The “insured person” definition in the SABS suggested that claims for nervous shock were limited to family members who qualified under section 3(1)(a)(ii).

Sterling v. Heartland Farm Mutual Inc. (20-000672)

The claimant sought entitlement to accident benefits after an incident in which she experienced intense neurological pain in her back and loss of sensation in her right leg and foot while pressing her foot onto the accelerator. Prior to starting the vehicle, the claimant had lifted her 30 pound son into his car seat. Vice Chair Boyce held that the incident qualified as an accident. Regarding the purpose test, the claimant lifting her son into his car seat and pressing on the accelerator were ordinary and well-known activities for which automobiles were used. Regarding the causation test, there was limited evidence about any intervening or distinct activity that was not part of the ordinary course of things. The claimant likely suffered reinjury to an earlier disc injury due to her use of her car.

Porter v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (2021 ONSC 3107)

The insurer appealed the Tribunal’s decision that the claimant was involved in an accident. The claimant slipped and fell on ice while making her way to a Lyft vehicle in her driveway. The Court granted the appeal and concluded that the facts of loss did not qualify as an accident. The Tribunal erred by conflating the “but for” test with the direct causation test. Entitlement to accident benefits required that the use or operation of the vehicle be a direct cause of the injuries. In this case, the car was at best ancillary to the incident. More was required than establishing that the location of the vehicle led to the incident occurring. Ice and snow was the direct cause of the injuries, which was insufficient to establish direct causation for accident benefits entitlement.

B.F. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (19-004944)

The claimant applied to Certas for accident benefits. Certas brought an application to the LAT arguing that the claimant was not involved in an “accident” and sought repayment of accident benefits because the claimant wilfully misrepresented facts in relation to her application for benefits. Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi agreed that the claimant was not involved in an accident. Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi considered the claimant’s EUO evidence as well as the evidence of Certas’ investigator. Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi found there were several inconsistencies with the claimant’s reporting and that the claimant could not describe basic facts regarding the collision at both her EUO and at the hearing. Because Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi found there was no accident, Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi also found that the claimant had wilfully misrepresented material facts about her claim for benefits and that the claimant had to repay Certas accident benefits pursuant to section 53.

Borsato v. Pembridge Insurance (19-013826)

A preliminary issues hearing was held to determine whether the claimant was involved in an “accident” as defined in s. 3(1) of the SABS. The claimant and insurer agreed on the following facts: On the day of the accident, the claimant drove to a feed store with her husband to purchase horse feed. The claimant and her husband were directed to pick up the horse feed from a shed. While walking from the shed to her car, the claimant had to navigate around a number of skids and pallets. While she was walking, the claimant raised her hand and clicked the key fob to remotely unlock her vehicle’s rear hatch so her husband could load the horse feed into the trunk. While clicking the key fob and observing the rear taillights of the vehicle flash, the claimant tripped over a slightly raised forklift tine. Adjudicator Parish found that the incident did not meet the purpose or causation test. In particular, this matter was distinguishable from previous LAT cases because the fall occurred prior to the vehicle being loaded with horse feed, the fall did not involve the claimant coming into contact with the vehicle, and the chain of causation was broken when the claimant parked her vehicle, shut it off, and locked the vehicle. Adjudicator Parish did not accept that pressing the key fob and observing the taillights flash established the use or operation of a vehicle. Adjudicator Parish found that the claimant was not involved in an “accident” as defined in the SABS. The application was dismissed.

Z.J. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (18-008967)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the decision of Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi wherein she found that the claimant was not in an accident. Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi upheld her previous decision. Adjudicator Maleki-Yazdi noted that the Tribunal reviewed all of the evidence, including the expert reports about whether the accident was staged, and that she did not err in her conclusion.

Allstate Canada v. Leroy Staglon (19-008347)

The claimant was riding his bicycle when he wound up in front of a vehicle operated by Allstate’s insured. The insurer argued that the automobile was not involved in the incident, and that the claimant had fallen independent of the automobile. Adjudicator Farlam held that the incident was not an accident. The claimant rode his bicycle up along side the stopped vehicle and put his hand on the driver’s hood. When the light changed, the claimant took his hand off the hood, started to ride, and then lost his balance and fell. The driver of the vehicle had not moved his vehicle and was still stopped when the claimant fell. Independent witnesses observed the claimant accosting the driver after the incident and police were called to the scene. The police investigation determined that the claimant had lost his balance, and the claimant was charged with assaulting the automobile driver. The police investigation noted that if the claimant’s bicycle had been struck by the vehicle there would have been damage to the bicycle or the vehicle, and no damage was observed on either. Adjudicator Farlam also noted that the claimant’s evidence was unreliable and inconsistent, nor was it corroborated by the testimony of any witnesses.

Edmonds v. COSECO Insurance Company (20-006226)

The claimant was injured when she slipped and fell while trying to enter her vehicle. The insurer denied that the incident qualified as an accident. Adjudicator Mazerolle agreed with the insurer and held that the incident was not an accident. The claimant slipped and fell on ice as she walked from her trunk to the driver’s door. She did not manage to open the door before falling. The adjudicator concluded that the dominant feature of the incident was falling on ice, rather than the use and operation of a vehicle. The vehicle was simply ancillary to the events. Adjudicator Mazerolle did not accept the claimant’s argument that the reason for her being near her car and on the ice – namely, in order to get into her car – was necessarily the direct cause of the incident.