Dhanji v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (19-010138)

The claimant disputed his entitlement to denied dental services and the remaining balance of a partially approved psychological treatment plan. Adjudicator Lake found that the claimant was not entitled to the proposed dental services or to the unapproved portion of psychological treatment. With respect to the dental services, she concluded that the claimant had not proven, on a balance of probabilities, that his tooth issue arose as a result of the accident. The claimant’s treating dental surgeon did not opine on or conclude that the claimant’s tooth issue was caused by the accident. Rather, he only stated that this was what was reported to him by the claimant. The unapproved portion of the proposed psychological treatment related to the treating psychotherapist’s hourly rate. The treatment plan sought funding for psychological counseling sessions with a regulated psychotherapist at a rate of $149.61 per hour. The insurer advised that fees could be billed for treatment by a psychotherapist at $58.19 per hour, but agreed in good faith to fund treatment at a rate of $100.00 per hour. Adjudicator Lake found that the claimant was not entitled to the unapproved portion of the psychological treatment plan, as he led no evidence that the psychotherapist specialized in CBT, nor did the treatment plan propose to provide any CBT treatment.

Biro v. Unica Insurance Inc. (20-003720)

The claimant was involved in an accident in 2007. In 2017, FSCO issued a decision granting the applicant ACBs and certain medical benefits. FSCO determined the claimant was not catastrophically impaired and denied a claim for NEBs. The claimant appealed the FSCO decision. The appeal was denied. In April 2020, the self-represented claimant applied to the LAT claiming $6 million for chiropractic services arising from the accident. Adjudicator McGee found that the LAT did not have jurisdiction to hear the application because the claimant had not filed a treatment plan as required under s. 38, and the insurer did not have the opportunity to approve or deny the benefit claimed in the LAT application. Adjudicator McGee found that without a denial of a benefit, the LAT did not have power under the Insurance Act to hear or decide on an application for benefits. The LAT application was dismissed. As the LAT did not have jurisdiction, Adjudicator McGee did not address the other grounds for dismissal raised by the insurer.

Moran v. Aviva General Insurance (19-008529)

The claimant applied to the LAT seeking entitlement to psychological and chiropractic treatment, an orthopaedic mattress, and various assessments. Causation was an issue as the claimant had a slip and fall incident and a second motor vehicle accident after the subject accident. Adjudicator Lake held that the “but for” test was the appropriate test for causation. Adjudicator Lake found that the claimant’s psychological impairments were caused by the subject accident. The claimant failed to prove on a balance of probabilities that his physical impairments were caused by the subject accident. The psychological benefits in dispute included the rate payable for a psychotherapist. Adjudicator Lake found that it was appropriate for Aviva to pay a psychotherapist at a lower rate than a psychologist. The claimant was not entitled to the disputed brokerage fee and the amount claimed for documentation and support. The claimant was not entitled to benefits related to physical impairments. The application was dismissed.

Kazmi v. Pembridge Insurance Company (19-010107 and 20-001345)

The claimant applied to the LAT disputing entitlement to IRBs and two medical benefits. The matter proceeded by way of written hearing. Adjudicator Farlam found that the claimant was entitled to an IRB at the rate of $291 per week and awarded the two medical benefits plus interest. With respect to IRBs, the parties agreed that substantive entitlement was not an issue. The insurer argued that the claimant was not entitled to an IRB pursuant to s. 33(6) because he failed to provide documentation necessary to adjust his claim. Adjudicator Farlam held that the claimant responded to the insurer’s requests and there was no valid suspension of benefits pursuant to s. 33. Adjudicator Farlam noted that the claimant had valid reasons for not complying with the insurer’s requests, including misunderstanding the nature of the insurer’s request for medical documents, and finding that the claimant gave best efforts to obtain the requested documents. With respect to the disputed cost of a mattress, Adjudicator Farlam awarded this benefit as she preferred the evidence of the claimant’s treating physician to that of the IE occupational therapist. Adjudicator Farlam held that the treating physician likely knew the claimant best, diagnosed the claimant with chronic back pain, and wrote to the insurer asking it to consider funding a firm mattress. Adjudicator Farlam agreed that the mattress was reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Farlam also awarded the cost of a chiropractic treatment plan based on the evidence of the claimant’s treating physicians, and noted that the claimant’s family physician wrote a letter to the insurer requesting it reinstate funding of chiropractic care.

D.C. v. Allstate Canada (19-005260)

The claimant sought entitlement to post-104 week IRBs, ACBs, and various medical benefits, as well as a special award. Vice-Chair McGee dismissed the application on the basis that the claimant had not established that the accident was the cause of the impairment giving rise to the claim. She found that the claimant sustained soft tissue injuries in the accident, from which he recovered, and that his ongoing impairments were related to a later slip and fall incident in which he injured his groin. In short, the accident was not a “but for” cause of any physical or psychological impairment. As the claimant had not established entitlement to the benefits claimed in the application, there was no basis for a special award.

Jeevakumaran v. Unifund (20-001025)

The claimant sought to be removed from the MIG and entitlement to medical benefits. Adjudicator Mazerolle concluded that the claimant established that he suffered from an accident-related psychological impairment. As such, he was no longer held to the funding and treatment limits of the MIG and s. 18(1) of the Schedule. Adjudicator Mazerolle found that the totality of the records established that psychological symptomology had affected some aspects of the claimant’s daily life. The medical benefits at issue were a psychological assessment, psychological services, and physical therapy. While Adjudicator Mazerolle accepted that the claimant suffered from a psychological impairment, he did not find that the proposed psychological services were payable, due to s. 47(2) of the Schedule. Once the insurer introduced the possibility of the claimant accessing publicly funded therapy through OHIP, the onus shifted to the claimant to rebut this proposition. What is more, the insurer supported this assertion by filing an information sheet from the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) that listed a number of publicly funded clinics and service providers—evidence that this treatment was (in the words of s. 47(2)) “reasonably available to the insured person”. However, Adjudicator Mazerolle could not draw the same conclusion about s. 47(2) for the psychological assessment, as there is no indication whether a similar service was “reasonably available” to be paid through OHIP. Therefore, Adjudicator Mazerolle found the psychological assessment to be payable by the insurer. Finally, Adjudicator Mazerolle was not satisfied that the physical therapy services were necessary for the claimant’s recovery as there was evidence that physical therapy was no longer assisting the claimant with his accident-related impairments.

A.A. v. Unifund Assurance Company (18-008999)

The insurer filed a request for reconsideration of a LAT hearing decision, in which the adjudicator found that the claimant was entitled to attendant care benefits at a reduced rate and medical expenses. The insurer submitted that the adjudicator erred in making the inference that because the claimant met the threshold for catastrophic impairment, she continued to meet the test for attendant care benefits. The insurer further argued that the adjudicator failed to apply the proper “but for” test for causation. Vice Chair Maedel found that the adjudicator applied the “but for” test in relation to the attendant care benefits analysis, and had not made any errors in fact or law that would have otherwise led to a different decision on the attendant care issue. Vice Chair Maedel found that the adjudicator did make an error in fact and law when she relied on the insurer’s previous approval of travel expenses to find that the current therapy services in dispute were reasonable and necessary and caused by the accident. Previous approval of a benefit was found to be irrelevant and cannot determine causation. Each treatment plan should be evaluated on whether the treatment can be causally linked to the accident and whether the treatments is reasonable and necessary. Vice Chair Maedel found that s. 46(5) does not entitle a claimant to automatic payment of incurred benefits following a catastrophic impairment designation. A claimant must still demonstrate the treatment is causally related to the accident and is reasonable and necessary. In addition, Vice Chair Maedel found that a catastrophically impaired claimant is not entitled to medical benefits that were incurred prior to submission of an OCF-18, even when an insurer has repeatedly denied medical benefits because the non-CAT limit had been reached. The request for reconsideration was granted in part.

D.L. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (19-000651)

The claimant sought entitlement to medical benefits, a social work assessment, an OCF-3 expense, and interest. Adjudicator Boyce concluded that the claimant was entitled to the three medical benefits, but not the assessment or expense. The insurer agreed to fund these treatment plans subject to a ruling with respect to the amounts proposed in excess of the maximum hourly rate in Superintendent’s Guideline No. 03/14. The insurer sought a breakdown of the services to be rendered, at what frequency or at what rate. Adjudicator Boyce found that treatment plans should clearly articulate the service provided and identify the provider and the appropriate rate. Adjudicator Boyce looked to the signing provider for each treatment plan and assumed that the provider’s area of expertise was the dominant modality for each. The applicable rate for each signing provider was then used to calculate the fees for each OCF-18. With respect to the assessment, Adjudicator Boyce found no reason to interfere with the insurer’s denial and that the type of assessment did not appear to be consistent with the claimant’s diagnosis and that there was no compelling medical evidence to indicate that a social worker assessment was required as a result of injuries sustained in the subject accident. Finally, the claimant sought $200 for an OCF-3 Disability Certificate. Adjudicator Boyce agreed with the insurer that the claimant submitting six OCF-3s from the same clinic in a three-year span was excessive where the claimant had not pointed to any change in circumstance. Further, neither the claimant, nor the clinic provided particulars to support why it was necessary to provide an updated OCF-3. Accordingly, Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant was not entitled to the expense because it was not reasonable or necessary.

Jamon v. The Co-operators (19-006256)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and various medical/rehabilitation benefits, including an attendant care assessment and functional abilities assessment. With respect to IRBs, Adjudicator Parish found that the claimant had proven on a balance of probabilities that she was substantially unable to perform the essential tasks of her pre-accident employment as a supervisor at Dairy Queen, emphasizing the claimant’s ongoing post-concussion symptoms, which were not addressed in the insurer’s IE reports. Adjudicator Parish further found that the attendant care assessment was reasonable and necessary because of the claimant’s self-reported difficulty with performing her personal care tasks, and that the functional abilities assessment was reasonable and necessary as it could have assisted with the determination of ongoing entitlement to IRBs. In light of her findings, Adjudicator Parish also granted a 25 percent special award on the attendant care and functional abilities assessment due to the insurer’s failure to investigate the claimant’s concussive symptoms.

Khosla v. TD General Insurance Company (19-010508)

The claimant applied to the LAT disputing her entitlement to a chiropractic treatment plan. The issue in this dispute was the application of sections 38(5) and (6), and the MIG. The insurer denied the treatment plan in accordance with section 38(5) on the basis that the claimant was being treated within the MIG. Later, the insurer removed the claimant from the MIG and the claimant argued that once the insurer removed the claimant from the MIG, it failed to reconsider its denial of the disputed treatment plan and failed to make a determination regarding its reasonableness and necessity. The insurer argued that it was entitled to deny the plan pursuant to section 38(5) as this section allows an insurer to refuse to accept a treatment plan if the plan described goods and services during any period which the insured person is entitled to receive goods and services within the MIG. The insurer submitted an OCF-21 for this period showing that the claimant was treated within the MIG. Adjudicator Lake held that the claimant was treated within the MIG when the disputed treatment plan was submitted and therefore, section 38(5) applied and the LAT was prevented from reviewing the denial of the plan pursuant to section 38(6), regardless of the fact the insurer later removed the claimant from the MIG.