K.W. v. Aviva General Insurance (18-006969)

The claimant requested a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision denying various medical benefits and IRBs, seeking an order quashing the decision and ordering a rehearing on all parts of the matter. Adjudicator Watt dismissed the applicant’s request, noting that his decision set out the evidence, the law, and why he gave more weight to some arguments over others. He emphasized that a reconsideration is not an opportunity to re-argue positions that previously failed before the Tribunal or to have evidence re-weighed.

A.L. v. Unica Insurance Inc. (18-008890)

The claimant sought a determination of a catastrophic impairment based on a WPI in excess of 55 percent. He also sought entitlement to ACBs, the denied portion of CAT assessments, and various medical benefits. Adjudicator Lake concluded that the claimant did not suffer a catastrophic impairment. She rejected the claimant’s experts opinions on WPI for mental or behavioural impairments because it relied on opinions from other experts which those experts later retracted. Even if all other WPI were accepted, the claimant would only have a 42 percent WPI. The ACBs claim was dismissed because it was for a period beyond the 104 week mark. Adjudicator Lake agreed with the claimant that CAT assessments were not paid out of the medical benefits limits, and found that six of proposed seven assessments were reasonable. Finally, Adjudicator Lake held that the treatment plans for further physiotherapy were reasonable and necessary, but that the claims for assistive devices, an attendant care assessment, and a two-part neuropsychological examination were not.

T.A. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-006820)

The Tribunal awarded NEBs, a psychological assessment, and a 25 percent special award. The Tribunal had ordered the insurer to pay NEBs due to its failure to respond to the claimant’s application, and such order required the insurer to pay NEBs before the conclusion of the 26 week waiting period. The insurer sought reconsideration. Adjudicator Lake partially granted the reconsideration. She amended the date on which NEBs began by one month, as the Tribunal erred in the date on which the OCF1 and OCF3 were submitted to the insurer. The special award on NEBs was rescinded because it was originally made based on the erroneous conclusion that the insurer had not responded to the claimant’s initial application.

T.A. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-006820)

The Tribunal awarded NEBs, a psychological assessment, and a 25 percent special award. The Tribunal had ordered the insurer to pay NEBs due to its failure to respond to the claimant’s application, and such order required the insurer to pay NEBs before the conclusion of the 26 week waiting period. The insurer sought reconsideration. Adjudicator Lake partially granted the reconsideration. She amended the date on which NEBs began by one month, as the Tribunal erred in the date on which the OCF1 and OCF3 were submitted to the insurer. The special award on NEBs was rescinded because it was originally made based on the erroneous conclusion that the insurer had not responded to the claimant’s initial application.

H.A. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-012325)

The claimant sought entitlement to the cost of an EMG study. Adjudicator Hines concluded that the insurer’s section 38 notice was non-compliant because it was too vague. However, the EMG study had been incurred 10 days (rather than 10 business days) after submission of the OCF-18. Because it was incurred too soon after submission of the OCF-18, it was not payable under section 38(11)(2).

A.A.J. v. Echelon General Insurance Company (19-000961)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs for a one month period when he was in non-compliance with IE requests, and a treatment plan for chiropractic services. Adjudicator Boyce rejected all of the excuses provided by the claimant for his non-attendance as being unreasonable or not believable. The insurer rescheduled the IEs on multiple occasions and the claimant was provided with notices to the address on his OCF-1 and to his counsel. The treatment plan was found not reasonable and necessary based on the opinions of IE assessors.

Z.A. v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company (19-001119)

The claimant sought entitlement to transportation expenses and a special award. Adjudicator Boyce dismissed both claims. The claimant failed to provide evidence regarding the transportation expenses, her home address, the address of the clinic, or an invoice for the transportation. Looking to the OCF-18, the longest one-way route between the addresses listed was well under the 50 kilometer deductible for non-catastrophic claims.

M.M. v. Aviva General Insurance (19-002201)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and three medical benefits. Adjudicator Chakravarti held that the claimant was not entitled to any of the claimed benefits. She found that the claimant was not credible, and that insufficient evidence was put forward to show that the claimant was working or had worked 26 of the past 52 weeks prior to the accident. The purported employer said that documents with his company name on the letterhead were misrepresentations. The claimant also failed to put forward convincing evidence regarding the three claimed medical benefits.

M.Z. v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance (19-005344)

The minor claimant suffered serious injuries in an accident. He received attendant care for over one year, but ACBs were terminated thereafter. He sought entitlement to further ACBs and one medical benefit for physiotherapy. Adjudicator Boyce denied the claim for further ACBs, but partially approved the claim for physiotherapy. The medical evidence suggested that the minor claimant had largely healed from his physical injuries within the year. The claimant’s treating surgeons and doctors had noted that the claimant’s injuries had resolved and the claimant was participating in normal activities. Adjudicator Boyce also noted that the claimant’s Form 1 oddly recommended support with activities that his parents were performing before the accident (meal preparation, bathroom cleaning). Further, there was no evidence of attendant care services being incurred.

J.Z. v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance (19-005337)

The minor claimant suffered a broken arm in an accident. He received attendant care for over one year, but ACBs were terminated thereafter. He sought entitlement to further ACBs and one medical benefit for physiotherapy. Adjudicator Boyce denied both claims. The medical evidence suggested that the minor claimant had largely healed from his physical injuries within the year. The claimant’s treating surgeons and doctors had noted that the claimant’s injuries had resolved and the claimant was participating in normal activities. Adjudicator Boyce also noted that there was no evidence of attendant care services being incurred.