F.K. v. TD Home and Auto Insurance Company (18-008114)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, ACBs, and psychological treatment. Adjudicator Gosio rejected the claims for NEBs and ACBs, and found that the psychological treatment plan was disputed more than two years after the denial. The claimant failed to lead sufficient evidence that the accident was the cause of her impairments, as she had extensive pre-accident injuries and impairments. Adjudicator Gosio also rejected the claimant’s argument that the “material contribution” test should apply. Regarding the claim for ACBs, the adjudicator again noted that the claimant was receiving personal care in relation to an earlier accident and that she failed to prove that further care was required as a result of the subject accident. The disputed psychological treatment was denied more than two years prior to the LAT application.

B.H.X. v. Aviva General Insurance (19-002556)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, a psychological assessment, and the cost of a plastic surgery consult. Adjudicator Norris dismissed the claims for NEBs and plastic surgery consult, but awarded the psychological assessment. The claimant failed to provide evidence supporting NEB entitlement, and his self-reporting suggested he was in fact more active after the accident, and he maintained independence with personal care, meal preparation, and household chores. The plastic surgery consult was incurred prior to the submission of the treatment plan, so it was not payable. The psychological assessment was found reasonable and necessary, but not payable because it was not incurred.

N.F. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-007077)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and a chronic pain assessment. In addition to denying entitlement to the claimed benefits, the insurer disputed what the weekly quantum of IRBs would be. Adjudicator Mazerolle concluded that the claimant was entitled to IRBs and the chronic pain assessment. The claimant worked as a restaurant manager and his accident-related impairments prevented him from his job demands. Adjudicator Mazerolle accepted that the quantum of IRB was to be determined based on a revised tax return (which supported IRBs of $400 per week), rather than the original tax return (which showed almost no pre-accident earnings)

Levey v. Aviva Insurance Company (19-006014)

The claimant applied to the LAT seeking entitlement to psychological services and the balance of a partially approved OCF-18 for driving lessons. Adjudicator Parish found that the claimant was not entitled to the disputed benefits. Adjudicator Parish noted that the OCF-18 for psychological services was completed by a psychologist, but the claimant previously received and only wanted therapy from a particular psychotherapist, who was not listed as the service provider on the OCF-18. The rates proposed on the OCF-18 were the rates for a psychologist, as per the Professional Services Guidelines. Adjudicator Parish did not accept that a psychotherapist should be paid the same rate as a psychologist. Adjudicator Parish also found that the psychological services were not payable as the claimant had failed to comply with the insurer’s section 33 requests. The balance of the partially approved OCF-18 for driving lessons was not payable as the hourly rates approved by the insurer were reasonable.

K.P. v. Aviva General Insurance (19-001985)

The claimant applied to the LAT seeking entitlement to a treatment plan for cannabis therapy. The claimant argued that the proposed benefits were reasonable and necessary for treatment of chronic pain and disturbed sleep. The insurer argued that the cannabis treatment was not reasonable and necessary as a result of the accident, as the claimant smoked marijuana for years prior to the accident and continued to smoke the same amount of marijuana after the accident. Adjudicator Boyce found that pain relief is a legitimate goal of treatment, and that the proposed cannabis treatment was reasonable and necessary.

R.A. v. Aviva Insurance Company (19-002890)

The claimant applied to the LAT for entitlement to ACBs, a variety of OCF-18s for treatment and assessments, the cost of a psychological pre-screen, the cost of two OCF-3s, and a special award. Based on monthly invoices for ACBs (all in the same amount), which did not particularize the exact dates or times services were provided or provide information about the service provider, Adjudicator Lake was unable to find on a balance of probabilities that the applicant had received attendant care services. Adjudicator Lake found that a failure to advise the claimant of eligibility for ACBs upon removal of the MIG did not constitute an unreasonable withholding or delaying of benefits. ACBs were not deemed to be incurred pursuant to section 3(8). Pursuant to s. 38(11), Adjudicator Lake found benefits proposed in multiple OCF-18s were payable because the insurer did not include specific details about the claimant’s medical condition in its denial letters. Adjudicator Lake found that the claimant was not entitled to ACBs, the cost of the psychological pre-screen, the cost of the two OCF-3s, chronic pain treatment, psychological treatment, a driver re-integration program, or OCF-18s that were duplicates of other approved OCF-18s. The claimant was entitled to shockwave therapy, a psychological assessment, a chronic pain assessment, and an exercise program.

K.P. v. Aviva General Insurance (19-001985)

The claimant disputed his entitlement to a treatment plan for medical cannabis, which the insurer denied based on an IE report that determined that medical cannabis was not reasonable and necessary to treat the claimant’s chronic pain. The insurer further noted that the claimant smoked marijuana daily for several years prior to the accident (and continued to do so after the accident), and argued that it was unreasonable for the claimant to ask the insurer to pay for the same amount of marijuana that he smoked previously. Nonetheless, Adjudicator Boyce held that the claimant was entitled to the cost of the treatment plan, plus interest, as it was reasonable and necessary. She preferred the recommendations of the claimant’s chronic pain specialist and cannabis clinic physician, who both believed that medical cannabis was appropriate, over the opinion of the IE assessor.

V.F. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (19-004249)

The claimant disputed his entitled to a treatment plan for physiotherapy services. Adjudicator Leslie found that the treatment plan was not reasonable and necessary, emphasizing the claimant’s significant pre-accident history of back pain (for which he was receiving regular physiotherapy treatment prior to the accident) and the fact that the insurer had approved ongoing physiotherapy services for 3.5 years post-accident. While Adjudicator Leslie accepted that the claimant may still have some pain, she was unable to determine whether 3.5 years of treatment had resolved the pain conditions caused by the accident and questioned whether the prolonged treatment reflected a sign of reasonableness/necessity for continued similar treatment, or whether it reflected a sign of dependence. She ultimately chose to prefer the evidence of the IE assessor who recommended that the claimant pursue self-directed activities rather than further facility based treatment.

J.R. v. Aviva Insurance Company (19-006160)

The claimant disputed his MIG determination, as well as entitlement to attendant care benefits in the amount of $138.09 per month and various medical benefits. Adjudicator Boyce found the claimant to be unsuccessful on all of the disputed issues. The claimant’s argument for removal from the MIG centred around his psychological impairments, relying on a psychological pre-screen interview report. Adjudicator Boyce did not find the pre-screen report compelling because it included no preliminary diagnosis or suggestion that the claimant met DSM-V criteria. Further, the claimant’s family doctor records made no reference to accident-related psychological complaints. As the claimant’s injuries fell within the MIG, he was not entitled to attendant care benefits or the disputed non-MIG treatment plans.

A.D. v. TD General Insurance Company (19-005432)

The claimant disputed his entitlement to in-home attendant care assessment. Section 20(2)(a) of the SABS states that no attendant care benefits are payable for expenses incurred more than 104 weeks post-accident unless the claimant sustained a catastrophic impairment. Given that the proposed assessment was requested over 6 years post-accident and the claimant was not catastrophically impaired, Adjudicator Hines determined that the claimant was not entitled to the disputed attendant care assessment.