C.D. v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company (18-006437)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of mileage expenses related to her case manager. Vice-Chair Lester upheld the previous decision and dismissed the reconsideration. She noted that the claimant re-argued her case from the previous decision, and did not explain how the decision erred in fact or law. She also did not argue as to how the mileage expenses were reasonable or necessary.

P.K. vs. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-011533)

The claimant disputed entitlement to a partially approved OCF-18 for psychological services in the amount of $3,591.87. The insurer paid $2,444.15 of the OCF-18 based upon the Professional Services Guideline for psychological services. Adjudicator Norris noted that the insurer was correct in its payment of the services within the PSG. He commented that the $224.42 per one hour session requested was not appropriate or in accordance with the PSG, while the $149.61 paid by the insurer was. The claimant also argued that the insurer was non-compliant with section 38 for delivering a late response which was “overly generic.” Adjudicator Norris agreed, noting that the denial letter was late and did not provide specific medical or other reasons for the denial. He awarded entitlement to the goods and services incurred during the period of non-compliance, staring on the 11th business day up to the day when the insurer provided a compliant notice.

E.M. v. The Guarantee Company of North America (18-000674)

The claimant filed a request for reconsideration following a decision in which the Tribunal concluded that he was not entitled to NEBs or various medical benefits. The claimant argued that the Tribunal erred in law by not engaging the Heath analysis and not considering evidence tendered at the hearing. Adjudicator Punyarthi dismissed the reconsideration request, noting that the Tribunal correctly cited the test for NEBs and appropriately weighed the evidence tendered at the hearing. It was beyond the scope of a reconsideration to engage in a re-weighing of the evidence.

E.M. v. The Guarantee Company of North America (18-000674)

The claimant filed a request for reconsideration following a decision in which the Tribunal concluded that he was not entitled to NEBs or various medical benefits. The claimant argued that the Tribunal erred in law by not engaging the Heath analysis and not considering evidence tendered at the hearing. Adjudicator Punyarthi dismissed the reconsideration request, noting that the Tribunal correctly cited the test for NEBs and appropriately weighed the evidence tendered at the hearing. It was beyond the scope of a reconsideration to engage in a re-weighing of the evidence.

Y.L.C. v. Gore Mutual Insurance Company (18-010499)

The claimant disputed his entitlement to chiropractic treatment and income replacement benefits. The insurer denied the proposed chiropractic treatment based on a physiatry IE report which found that further facility-based treatment would not be helpful. Vice Chair Lester nevertheless determined that the disputed treatment plan was reasonable and necessary, given the records from the treating facility which showed ongoing improvements in the claimant’s range of motion and the fact that the claimant’s family physician had recently referred him to a chronic pain clinic for the same types of issues he complained of to the physiatry assessor. Vice Chair Lester concluded that she did not have jurisdiction to deal with the merits of the IRB claim, as the insurer had not denied entitlement to IRBs but rather suspended entitlement for failure to comply with a section 33 request for production of financial documentation.

A.A. v. Technology Insurance Company Inc. (18-007493)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to chiropractic services and rebuttal assessments. Adjudicator Paluch concluded that the claimant suffered from chronic pain syndrome, which was not simply a clinically associated sequela to his minor injuries. There was also evidence of disc bulges, protrusion and canal stenosis which are not minor injuries. The claimant was awarded the chiropractic treatment since it provided him with pain relief. The rebuttal assessments were not payable because there was no evidence as to the purpose of the assessment or why a rebuttal report was necessary.

K.K. v. Coseco Insurance (18-002839)

The claimant disputed his MIG determination and entitlement to various medical benefits. The respondent raised a preliminary issue, arguing that the claimant was statute-barred from proceeding with his claim in respect of two of the disputed treatment plans for failure to dispute entitlement within the two year limitation period. Adjudicator Norris agreed, noting that the insurer’s denial letters were clear and unequivocal denials of the benefits and included notice of the two year limitation period, information on the claimant’s right to dispute, and medical and other reasons for the denial. Adjudicator Norris further concluded that the claimant had not met his onus of establishing that his injuries fell outside of the MIG, and was thus bound by the $3,500 funding limit.

K.W. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-006959)

The claimant applied to the LAT seeking entitlement to IRBs, the benefits proposed in two treatment plans, and a special award. The insurer conceded that the claimant qualified for IRBs during the disputed period but contested the quantum of IRBs being claimed. Adjudicator Watt held that post-accident “passive” income earned by a claimant was to be included as a deduction in any calculation under s. 4 and 7 of the SABS, and found that the self-employed claimant was entitled to IRBs in the amount calculated by the insurer’s expert accountant. The claimant was not entitled to a psychological assessment, psychological treatment, or a special award. The psychological assessment was not reasonable and necessary as the claimant had already undergone two assessments. Adjudicator Watt found that the services proposed in the OCF-18 for psychological treatment were not reasonable and necessary, including costs for consultation, communication with the treatment providers, periodic administration, scoring and interpretation of psychological tests, review of external file materials and preparation of status reports and overseeing supervision of another psychologist.

J.A. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-011393)

The claimant applied to the LAT seeking entitlement to the benefits proposed in three treatment plans. Adjudicator Norris found that the proposed chiropractic treatment plan was not reasonable and necessary, but as the insurer’s initial denial letter was non-compliant with s. 38 “medical and other all reasons” requirements, the claimant was entitled to payment for the goods and services incurred during the period from the 11th business day following receipt of the treatment plan to the date a compliant notice was provided. The claimant was entitled to the balance of a psychological assessment because the partial approval letter was not clear and unequivocal. The claimant was not entitled to the balance of a psychological treatment plan because the proposed services (communication with other treatment providers, treatment planning, and preparation of a progress report) were found to be not reasonable and necessary.

N.S v. Wawanesa Insurance Company (19-000300)

The claimant sought a determination that her impairments were outside of the MIG and entitlement to medical benefits proposed in two treatment plans. Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant’s psychological and/or neurological impairment took her outside of the MIG, based on the medical opinions of her assessors. The claimant was subsequently found entitled to payment for a psychological assessment. However, Adjudicator Boyce found a chiropractic treatment plan not payable as it was not reasonable and necessary. The claimant failed to demonstrate that her pain was caused by the accident or that she required further facility-based intervention to achieve relief.