S.L. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (19-002783)

The claimant sought entitlement to income replacement benefits and to medical benefits proposed in eight treatment plans, and the cost of $26,400 for catastrophic impairment assessments. The claimant argued that he suffered from pre-existing lower back pain which was exacerbated as a result of the accident and would prevent him from reaching maximum recovery under the MIG. Adjudicator Lester found that the claimant’s pre-existing strains did not remove him from the MIG and the claimant did not have a chronic pain disorder, therefore, the MIG limits applied. Adjudicator Lester concluded that the claimant exhausted all funding under the MIG and he was not entitled to any of the treatment plans in dispute. Adjudicator Lester found that the claimant suffered a substantial inability to perform the essential tasks of his employment and was entitled to IRB for a period of four months. Adjudicator Lester noted that the claimant was also entitled to interest for the IRB.

Aviva General Insurance v. Khan (2020 ONSC 1290)

The insurer sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to award various medical benefits. The Court reviewed the Tribunal’s decision on a correctness standard and dismissed the appeal. It agreed with the insurer that a benefit could not be deemed incurred without a specific finding that the insurer unreasonably withheld or delayed payment of a benefit. However, the Court also wrote that the Tribunal’s decision made it clear that the benefit had been incurred because the services were provided and the claimant owed money to the treatment provider.

S.F. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (18-012486)

The claimant sought entitlement to the costs of three assessments for examinations and one treatment plan for assistive devices. Adjudicator Norris found that the claimant was not entitled to any of the benefits. Adjudicator Norris concluded that the Neurological, FAE, and In-Home Ergonomics assessments were not reasonable and necessary as a result of the accident. The claimant did not submit the disputed treatment plan, and as a result Adjudicator Norris had to rely on the IE report. Adjudicator Norris concluded that the treatment plan was not reasonable and necessary as the devices were predominately for neck, back, and shoulder injuries and the claimant reported no such impairments.

S.P. v. Jevco (19-001613)

The claimant sought entitlement to income replacement benefits, to the costs of four assessments for examinations, to four treatment plans for physiotherapy services, and to payment for a disability certificate invoice. Adjudicator Watt found that the claimant was not entitled to the medical benefits, attendant care assessment, psychological assessment, functional abilities evaluation, and chronic pain assessment. In determining entitlement to IRB, Adjudicator Watt relied on the opinions of the IE assessors who indicated that the claimant could perform her pre-accident duties. Adjudicator Watt concluded that there was no evidence before the Tribunal to show that the claimant’s pain was severe enough to cause functional impairment or disability, so the IRB claim was dismissed. Finally, Adjudicator Watt found that the disability certificate invoice was not reasonable and necessary.

M.D. v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company (18-011652)

The claimant sought a determination that his impairments were outside of the MIG and entitlement to medical benefits proposed in two treatment and assessment plans for physiotherapy services and a chronic pain assessment. Adjudicator Grant found that the claimant’s chronic pain took him outside of the MIG, based on the chronic pain assessment report of Dr. Karmy, a chronic pain specialist. Based on the length and history of the claimant’s pain complaints and the goal of achieving pain relief, Adjudicator Grant found the chronic pain assessment and physiotherapy treatment plan to be reasonable and necessary.

D.S. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (17-006952)

The claimant sought entitlement to the cost of a psychological assessment and a special award. Adjudicator McQuaid found that the assessment was reasonable and necessary, as the evidence from the ongoing adjustment of the claim supported the need for a psychological assessment. The result of assessments and examinations by four different doctors was a recommendation for psychotherapy treatment. Adjudicator McQuaid found the cost of the examination to be payable but did not grant a special award, finding the insurer’s denial of the cost of the examination was not per se frivolous and vexatious conduct.

Applicant v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (18-000605)

The claimant sought a catastrophic impairment determination, entitlement to attendant care benefits, and the cost of various assessments. The claimant suffered from chronic pain, had not worked in the 10 years since the accident, and had been diagnosed with major depressive disorder. Pain prevented the claimant’s participation in home-based activities, and she rarely left the house. Adjudicator Parish found that the claimant suffered a Class 4 marked impairment in activities of daily living (no other spheres of function were found to be Class 4). In terms of the WPI, Adjudicator Parish would have assigned 40 percent for the psychological impairment and 7 percent for physical impairment, meaning that the claimant did not have a 55 percent WPI. Adjudicator Parish awarded retroactive ACBs of $507.03 per month for assistance with meal preparation. She rejected the claims for grooming (the claimant was capable of independent hair care), bathroom cleaning (which was found to be housekeeping, not attendant care); and basic supervisory care (the Form 1 category was for emergency assistance, but the claimant did not lack the capacity to respond to an emergency; emotional care was not an appropriate attendant care service). Adjudicator Parish also awarded the cost of an OT situational assessment related to the catastrophic impairment application. She also awarded the cost of the in-home assessment to complete the Form 1. Adjudicator Parish also held that the claimant was not required to meet the strict “incurred” definition for payment of ACBs, because the accident occurred in 2009. Interest was awarded on ACBs, but only from the date the Form 1s were submitted.

C.S. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-007039)

The claimant sought entitlement to a rehabilitation treatment plan and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Grant found that the claimant did not demonstrate that the rehabilitation benefits in dispute for personal training and a gym membership were reasonable and necessary. The treatment plan was contradicted by the claimant’s self-reporting that she had already received education about stretching and strengthening, as well as Dr. Kleinman’s report on the extent of the claimant’s injuries and recommended treatment. The treatment plan was found not payable.

S.P.F. v. Aviva General Insurance (18-010856)

The claimant sought entitlement to medical benefits proposed in two psychological treatment plans. Adjudicator Grant found that the treatment plans were not reasonable and necessary, based on the claimant’s self-reporting and the reports of section 44 assessors. The claimant had acknowledged that he had not experienced any significant disruption, and he denied a desire to participate in psychotherapy counselling. Adjudicator Grant also noted that if the claimant required further psychological treatment, he still had approximately $3,879.00 of approved and not incurred funding available for treatment.

Applicant v. Unifund Assurance Company (18-008089)

The insurer filed a request for reconsideration arising from a decision in which the Tribunal found that CAT Assessments were not a medical benefit and therefore their funding did not fall within the $50,000 limit under section 18 of the SABS. Adjudicator Victor dismissed the insurer’s request for reconsideration and granted the claimant’s request for costs in the amount of $100, noting that the insurer had only raised the same arguments it made at the hearing and was essentially trying to re-litigate the decision based on the same arguments.