F.E. v. Intact Insurance Company (18-011405)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs, various medical benefits, and two assessments. The insurer brought motions for section 33 non-compliance for failure to provide records in the Case Conference Order, and a section 55 defence for IE non-attendance. Both motions were dismissed. Section 33 was not found to apply because the claimant’s breach was of the LAT Rules as opposed to a section 33 request. The section 55 defence was dismissed because of the insurer’s failure to provide notice of the issue. Adjudicator Paluch concluded that the claimant was not entitled to IRBs because he failed to provide evidence necessary to establish either a substantial or complete inability to perform the essential tasks of his employment, and there was evidence that he returned to work following the accident. The medical benefits and assessments were also dismissed due to the claimant’s lack of evidence and poor credibility.

H.S.H. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (18-002204)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of the cost of a catastrophic impairment assessment, arguing that the burden should not be on the claimant and that the “reasonable and necessary” test did not apply to section 25. Adjudicator Reilly dismissed the reconsideration request, holding that the “reasonable and necessary” test applied to each catastrophic impairment assessment, and that the burden was on the claimant to prove that the test was satisfied.

A.G. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (19-001973)

The claimant sought a special award in relation to the cost for medical cannabis. The insurer had requested information from the claimant regarding the costs for the medical cannabis in order to consider payment. The claimant responded, but only provided some of the information requested by the insurer. Adjudicator Parish noted the insurer should have identified all the specific required information in order to obtain funding for the cannabis in its initial request for information in the OCF-9 of November 2, 2018. Adjudicator Parish further indicated that although, the insurer subsequently sent a letter dated December 17, 2018 that reiterated the same information that was required, it did not equate to the insurer unreasonably withholding or delaying payments to the claimant. On December 21, 2018, the insurer sent a new letter that clearly outlined the specific information that was required for payment of the costs of the cannabis. Since the insurer paid the costs within 30 days of receiving the requested information, Adjudicator Parish found that there was no delay in the chronology of events in the insurer’s response for the claim.

M.M. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-006475)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs, various medical benefits, educational expenses, and an accounting report. Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant was not entitled to payment of IRBs as claimed as she did not demonstrate a substantial inability to perform the essential tasks of her pre-accident employment for the period in dispute. Adjudicator Boyce had noted inconsistencies in the claimant’s IRB claim about her ability to complete her essential pre-accident employment tasks and that the claimant was able to return to work. The surveillance evidence was found to show the claimant doing many routine work tasks that contradicted her claim she was unable to work. She also claimed the cost of the accounting report she completed to calculate her IRB quantum, which was determined to be not payable because it was not an identified issue in dispute. The claimant was found to be entitled to payment for physiotherapy treatment and dental expenses including interest as they were considered to be reasonable and necessary. Further, the claimant was not entitled to the education expenses claimed as there was no evidence to support that she was unable to complete her course as a result of the accident. No special award was granted as there was no indication that Aviva unreasonably withheld or delayed payment of benefits where there was also a genuine dispute over entitlement.

A.P. v. Aviva Insurance Canada(18-007997)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, medical benefits proposed in three treatment plans, and the cost of examination expense for an orthopaedic assessment. Adjudicator Grieves concluded that the claimant was not entitled to NEBs as the claimant failed to prove that he suffered a complete inability to carry on a normal life. Adjudicator Grieves found that all disputed medical benefits proposed in the three treatment plans were reasonable and necessary, and disagreed with s. 44 IE conclusions that the claimant had reached maximal recovery. Lastly, Adjudicator Grieves also found the cost of examination expense for an orthopaedic assessment was reasonable as it was related to the assessment of accident-related injuries.

M.S. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-007082)

The claimant sought entitlement to four treatment plans for medical rehabilitation and cost of examinations, including chiropractic treatment, concussive therapy, and optometric services. Vice-Chair McQuaid found that the proposed treatments were not payable. In her decision, she noted that, although, she gave more weight to the evidence provided by the claimant’s family physician and treating practitioners over the IE assessors, the records and evidence provided by the claimant did not contain any recommendations by the family physician for any of the disputed treatment plans for physical therapy. The remaining treatments for optometric services were denied as the claimant had pre-existing cataracts, which were not caused by the subject accident, and the medical records indicated that, although concussive symptoms were present, that they had fully resolved by the time the concussive therapy was proposed.

R.B. v. RSA Insurance (19-002329)

The claimant sought entitlement to four treatment plans for medical rehabilitation and cost of examinations, including a catastrophic impairment assessment and medications. The insurer denied the benefits in dispute on the basis that the claimant’s medical limits had been exhausted. Adjudicator Kaur concluded that that cost of examination for a catastrophic assessment are not subject to the medical benefits limitation. The claimant was entitled to the catastrophic impairment assessments, but the remainder of the medical benefits were denied as there was no evidence on a balance of probabilities that the expenses were reasonable or necessary.

H.M. v. Intact Insurance Company (18-003979)

The claimant sought entitlement to a treatment plan for physiotherapy, and cost of examinations for a neurological assessment and a chronic pain assessment. Adjudicator Johal reviewed the medical records on file, which indicated numerous treating practitioners’ opinion that further physiotherapy would be beneficial, and concluded that the disputed treatment for ongoing physiotherapy was reasonable and necessary as the claimant did not have to prove his injuries were “substantive”, only that the need for the treatment was reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Johal dismissed the claims for the denied examination for a neurology assessment as the treating neurologists on file did not recommend it in their records, and in fact, only recommended further physiotherapy. The chronic pain assessment was denied because while the treating practitioner diagnosed the claimant with chronic pain, there was no indication that a further assessment was required.

S.A. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (19-000995)

The claimant disputed entitlement to two treatment plans for treatments focused on neurological and concussive injuries. Adjudicator Norris noted that the claimant appeared to have predominantly psychological injuries as a result of the accident. He cited the insurer examination reports of Dr. Smyth (neurologist) and Dr. Belfon (physician) as holding greater weight than the claimant’s evidence. Adjudicator Norris also noted that primary reason for the claimant’s visits to her family doctor was in fact to report psychological symptoms, and not symptoms related to neurological or concussive symptoms. He also gave little weight to the section 25 report of Dr. Horseman (chiropractor) as it was not accompanied by any records or test results to substantiate Dr. Horseman’s conclusions. Adjudicator Norris found the treatment plans not reasonable and necessary and denied any interest.

A.H. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-004237)

The claimant disputed her entitlement to a treatment plan for chiropractic services. Vice-Chair Farlam concluded that the disputed treatment plan was not necessary. Although the claimant consistently complained of back pain from 2015 to 2019, a review of the medical evidence did not show a direct relation to proposed treatments and subject accident as the claimant had pre-existing back pain, had been involved in two prior accidents, and the subject accident was only directly mentioned a few times; and at one point, was not mentioned for a period of two years.