O.R.O. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-007650)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of disputed medical benefits. Adjudicator Baker was not persuaded that there was an error in law committed by the Tribunal and that the claimant’s reconsideration was a request to re-litigate the dispute.

V.R. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-002880)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision not to award various medical benefits. Adjudicator Flude rejected the request. He wrote that the reconsideration request was essentially a request that the Tribunal reverse its findings of fact and prefer the claimant’s assessor over the insurer’s assessor. The reconsideration request was dismissed.

A.B. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-004653)

The claimant sought entitlement to physiotherapy and the cost of an occupational therapy assessment conducted as part of a catastrophic impairment assessment. She also argued that HST was not part of the medical benefits limits. Adjudicator Ferguson accepted that HST was payable outside of the medical benefits limits. He concluded that the occupational therapy assessments were not payable because no physician was involved in completion of the OCF-19, and an occupational therapist was not qualified to complete the OCF-19 independently. The disputed medical benefits were also denied.

M.S. v. Dominion of Canada General Insurance (19-000579)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to six medical benefits. Adjudicator Norris held that the MIG applied to the claimant’s injuries. There was no evidence that the claimant’s pre-existing medical issues would impact his recovery under the MIG. He also held that the alleged psychological injuries and chronic pain were not outside of the “minor injury” definition.

N.D. v. Aviva Insurance Company (18-009345)

The claimant sought entitlement to three medical benefits. Adjudicator Victor dismissed all of the claims. She held that the claimant could not prove that the partially denied psychological treatment was reasonable and necessary, and that further physical therapy was reasonable and necessary. The claimant had returned to work, had full range of motion, and was participating in activities of daily living.

J.W. v. Wawanesa Insurance (18-003407)

The claimant suffered catastrophic injuries in Quebec in 2000. She elected to receive no fault benefits under the Quebec SAAQ. Over time, Ontario had raised its hourly rates for service providers, while Quebec’s hourly rates remained lower. The claimant argued that despite receiving Quebec no fault benefits, she should be entitled to payment at the Ontario hourly rates for service providers. Adjudicator Flude rejected the claimant’s position, holding that once she had elected to receive Quebec no-fault benefits, she was to be treated as a Quebec resident under the Quebec SAAQ for the duration of her no fault claim.

M.C. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-006840)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, psychological services, and a psychological assessment. Adjudicator Watt found that the claimant had not proven that he met the requirements to qualify for NEBs, in light of evidence that the claimant had minimal physical functional impairment and the claimant’s own evidence under oath that he was able to perform all self-care tasks and had no functional limitations from the accident. Adjudicator Watt did not find psychological services and a psychological assessment reasonable or necessary since the claimant admitted in examination under oath that he was not claiming any psychological issues as a result of the accident.

S.S. v. RBC Insurance Company (18-000222)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs, a social work assessment, the cost of completing three disability certificates, and interest. Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant did not meet the stringent test to qualify for NEBs. The claimant stated that her pain improved with treatment and was not debilitating; she also reported independently carrying out her daily routines and self-care. As such, while Adjudicator Boyce acknowledged that test did not require the claimant to be bed-ridden, he held that the test demanded more evidence of impaired functionality and inability. Adjudicator Boyce did not find a social work assessment reasonable or necessary since there was no evidence that the assessment could address the claimant’s specific complaints. Adjudicator Boyce also did not find the cost of completing the three disability certificates to be reasonable or necessary since the insurer did not request them and they failed to provide new or additional information about the claimant’s impairments.

A.A. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (18-00856)

The claimant sought entitlement to physiotherapy, a driver evaluation assessment, a neurological assessment, and interest. Adjudicator Watt found the following: the claimant was not entitled to a driver evaluation assessment since she had already been assessed and returned to driving; there was insufficient evidence to suggest that a neurological assessment would have a rehabilitative purpose leading to a reduction of pain, so such an assessment was not reasonable or necessary; and no interest was payable to the claimants since no benefits were owed to her.

K.H. v. Gore Mutual Insurance Company (18-009689)

The claimant sought entitlement to a treatment plan that included physiotherapy, massage therapy, and swim passes, interest on the payment of overdue benefits, and a special award. Adjudicator Norris found that the claimant was entitled to the disputed treatment because it was reasonable and necessary to address the claimant’s ongoing pain and functional limitations. The claimant was diagnosed with chronic pain syndrome and there was evidence that her ongoing pain symptoms responded well to treatment. However, Adjudicator Norris did not find that the insurer’s conduct warranted the claimant’s entitlement to a special award: the claimant argued that the respondent acted unreasonably in failing to redact the assessor’s prognosis from the insurer’s examination report when prognosis was an issue the parties agreed to omit from the insurer’s examination requisition prior to scheduling the assessment; however, Adjudicator Norris found no obligation, legislative or otherwise, for the insurer to redact/revise the report. The claimant was awarded interest on the payment of the disputed treatment plan.