S.S.R. v. Unifund Assurance Company (18-004772)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s award of NEBs and medical benefits, and that section 55 did not prevent the claimant from disputing entitlement to the medical benefits. Vice Chair Lester granted the reconsideration in relation to NEBs, but only in ordering that NEB entitlement began six months after the accident as opposed to four weeks, since the claim was under a transitional policy. The reconsideration was dismissed in relation to entitlement to benefits because no error in law was identified by the insurer and the findings of fact were permissible based on the evidence before the Tribunal. In terms of IE non-attendance, Vice Chair Lester noted that section 55 would only apply if the IEs in question were in relation to a disputed benefit. The notices of examination did not indicate which medical benefits were being addressed, so the Tribunal could not determine if section 55 applied.

J.P. v. Allstate Insurance Company (18-008027)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and eight medical benefits. Adjudicator Boyce rejected the claims. He held that the claimant failed to adduce sufficient objective evidence of a substantial inability to engage in his pre-accident employment. All of his evidence was self-reported. Further, the claimant did not use any prescriptions to address his soft tissue injuries or pain. Adjudicator Boyce also rejected all of the claimed medical benefits. First, he noted that section 38(5) prevented the claimant from disputing entitlement to any OCF-18s while treatment remained under the MIG. With regard to two late denials, Adjudicator Boyce noted that any incurred treatment would be payable, but that the claimant failed to provide evidence that any treatment was incurred during the period of non-compliance.

A.G. v. Coseco Insurance (18-007969)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG, entitlement to a chronic pain assessment and chronic pain program, and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Sharda found that the claimant should be removed from the MIG since the chronic pain she suffered in her neck and left shoulder were not predominantly minor injuries. Adjudicator Sharda further found compelling evidence of the claimant’s pre-existing medical condition; her chronic injuries prevented her from achieving maximal medical recovery from the injuries that were exacerbated by the accident. Additionally, Adjudicator Sharda found that the claimant’s chronic pain injuries had continued over four years post-accident and therefore by definition were chronic. The claimant was thus entitled to the chronic pain treatment plan and the chronic pain assessment, as both were reasonable and necessary, and interest.

D.O. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-007687)

The claimant sought entitlement to various chiropractic treatment plans, a functional cognitive assessment, and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Norris found the following: since the claimant incurred the disputed chiropractic treatment plans prior to their submission and without prior approval of the insurer or meeting any of the other exceptions under section 38(2), he was not entitled to payment for them; the claimant was not entitled to the disputed functional cognitive assessment as it was not reasonable and necessary because no further investigation into the claimant’s cognitive state was required (specifically, the claimant’s evidence failed to show signs of cognitive impairment significant enough to impair his independence with personal care and ability to complete activities of work and normal living, as suggested in the disputed treatment and assessment plan); and the claimant was thus not entitled to interest.

Z.K. v. Unifund Assurance Company (18-007924)

The claimant sought entitlement to four physiotherapy treatment plans and the cost of an impairment assessment, a multi-disciplinary catastrophic assessment, and a neurological assessment. Adjudicator Manigat rejected the opinion of the insurer’s psychiatry assessor that there was no objective evidence of ongoing impairments and that the claimant did not have any functional limitations or physical restrictions, finding instead that the physiotherapy treatment plans were reasonable and necessary to manage the claimant’s chronic pain. The claimant was not entitled to the cost of the impairment assessment because a comprehensive impairment assessment had already been completed; nor was he entitled to the catastrophic assessment or neurological assessment, as his injuries were predominantly physical in nature.

M.A. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (18-006614)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG, entitlement to various medical/rehabilitation benefits (which were denied due to the insurer’s position that the MIG applied to the claimant’s injuries), and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Kaur found that the claimant’s pre-existing conditions did not remove him from the MIG and that he sustained predominantly minor injuries as a result of the accident (his family physician’s notes consistently referred to his injury as a sprain; psychologically, while these notes documented the claimant’s emotional symptoms, they were not sufficient to warrant MIG removal). Since Adjudicator Kaur found the claimant’s injuries to be predominantly minor in nature, he did not have to address whether the disputed treatment plans were reasonable and necessary.

H.W.G. v. Dominion of Canada General Insurance Company (Travelers) (18-000126)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to a psychological assessment, chiropractic treatment, and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Corapi found that the claimant established on a balance of probabilities that her injuries were not predominantly minor injuries because of her psychological injuries; the claimant’s depression and anxiety did not fall within the definition of “minor injury.” Adjudicator Corapi was also persuaded that there was sufficient evidence of a severe psychological condition to warrant further investigation and that the psychological assessment was therefore reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Corapi further found the chiropractic treatment plans to be reasonable and necessary in treating the claimant’s continuing physical pain. The claimant was therefore entitled to the disputed assessment and treatment, and interest on the overdue payment of benefits.

M.B. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (19-000030)

The claimant sought entitlement to psychological treatment, a chronic pain program, and interest on the payment of overdue benefits. Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant was entitled to the portion of the disputed psychological treatment plan for psychological sessions; however, with respect to the remaining elements of the disputed treatment plan, he agreed with the insurer’s position that there were other methods of determining the effectiveness of treatment aside from a progress report, and transportation was not required since the clinic was close to the claimant’s home. With respect to the disputed chronic pain program, Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant’s complaints of pain to her family physician and treating practitioners were “consistent, continuous and voluminous.” As such, Adjudicator Boyce found on the evidence that the chronic pain program was partially reasonable and necessary: the rehabilitative components were well-supported by the documentation and he agreed that one progress report would be beneficial, but he did not find that a second progress report or the social work and education elements of the plan were reasonable and necessary.

D.K. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (18-010057)

The claimant sought entitlement to NEBs and medical/rehabilitation benefits. Adjudicator Boyce found that the claimant did not suffer a complete inability to carry on a normal life, agreeing with the findings in the insurer’s examination reports; while the reports noted headaches and intermittent neck and back pain, Adjudicator Boyce found it was “a stretch to equate these impairments to having a complete inability to carry on a normal life.” Adjudicator Boyce further found that the claimant was entitled to an orthopedic assessment and psychological treatment since the insurer had indeed approved these treatment plans. The claimant was not entitled to any of the other disputed examinations and treatment plans since he had not met his burden to prove they were reasonable and necessary.

J.P. v. Aviva General Insurance Company (18-007398)

The claimant sought entitlement to various medical/rehabilitation benefits, interest on the payment of overdue benefits, and a special award. In this amended decision, Adjudicator Punyarthi preferred the claimant’s evidence over the insurer’s, finding that it persuasively demonstrated the claimant was entitled to the disputed benefits. Adjudicator Punyarthi further found that the claimant was entitled to a special award since the insurer provided reasons for denial to the claimant that were not consistent with its actual reasons for denial, and failed to consider medical treatment records on file when deciding to deny the claimant’s requests for treatment. By engaging in this conduct, Adjudicator Punyarthi found that the insurer unreasonably delayed or withheld payments to the claimant; as such, the insurer was ordered to pay an award to the claimant of 50 percent of the denied benefits (and interest) at issue. Adjudicator Punyarthi noted that the insurer’s omissions were a significant breach of its obligations to the claimant and that an award at the maximum 50 percent was thus warranted.