Applicant v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-001040)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical treatment plans. The insurer denied each as not being reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Eleanor White reviewed the medical evidence and found half of the treatment plans reasonable and necessary. Interest, in accordance with section 51, was awarded on the payable benefits.

T. T. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-002535)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical treatment plans. The insurer denied the treatment and asserted a MIG position. The insurer also tendered surveillance in support of its position, to which the claimant sought to exclude on the basis of bad faith. Adjudicator Avvy Go determined that the surveillance was in contravention of Rule 9.2 and was not served 10 days prior to the hearing. Moreover, a case conference Order stipulated timelines that the insurer was in contravention of without any explanation. Accordingly, the materials were excluded. Additionally, the insurer was ordered to pay costs on the motion to exclude. However, on the substantive merits of the claim, Adjudicator Go determined that the claimant had not tendered compelling evidence to demonstrate that recovery within the MIG was unavailable; as a result, none of the treatment plans were found payable.

Applicant v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada (17-001523)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical benefits, as well as attendant care benefits. The insurer denied the medical treatment asserting the claims were not reasonable and necessary. The insurer also denied the claimant’s attendant care claim and cited a lower attendant care rate commissioned by an IE assessor. Adjudicator Billeh Hamud reviewed the medical evidence and preferred the evidence of the insurer’s attendant care assessor, which was not rebutted. Accordingly, attendant care benefits were awarded at the rate of the insurer. Moreover, because only one of the attendant care providers was qualified, the award for attendant care was confined to the expenses of the one PSW. As it pertained to the medical benefits claimed, Adjudicator Hamud determined that fees attached to the submission of treatment plans were compliant with Superintendent Guideline No. 03/14 and therefore payable. The substantive treatment sought, with the exception of a progress report, was considered not reasonable and necessary on review of the medical evidence.

Applicant v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance (17-001228)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical benefits. The insurer denied the treatment asserting the claims were not reasonable and necessary. On review of the medical evidence, Adjudicator Eleanor White determined that the medical benefits sought were payable, with the exception of a neuropsychological examination. A gym membership and assistive devices were also found partially payable. Interest, pursuant to section 51, was also awarded.

Applicant v. TD Insurance (17-003356)

The claimant sought entitlement to medical benefits, including a number of prescription expenses. The insurer raised a causation argument as the claimant’s medical history was littered with previous MVAs and workplace injuries. The claimant countered by noting the insurer previously approved treatment, which would suggest the insurer accepted the subject motor vehicle accident as the cause of the claimant’s impairments. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson reviewed the medical evidence and determined the MVA was the cause of the claimant’s injuries. Since the insurer did not object to the reasonableness of medication claimed, the medication was considered payable. The treatment sought, however, was consider not payable as the claimant failed to prove the treatment was reasonable and necessary.

K.A. v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada (17-002023)

The claimant sought entitlement to three treatment plans. Adjudicator Avvy Go reviewed the medical evidence and determined that the claim for assistive devices was reasonable; however, the claim for chiropractic services was not reasonable. It was also noted that the claimant had not exhausted all previously approved treatment plans.

Applicant v. Allstate Canada (17-004793)

The claimant sought entitlement to one treatment plan. The insurer denied the treatment plan as not being reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson reviewed the evidence of each party and determined that the insurer’s IE reports were more credible and the claimant’s reports did not have corroborating support from clinical notes and records. The claim was dismissed.

Applicant v. TTC Insurance Company Limited (17-002561)

The claimant sought a declaration that she suffered a catastrophic impairment as a result of the accident, and entitlement to a psychological paper review. The claimant had submitted two OCF-19s – the first alleged a catastrophic impairment due to a 55 percent Whole Person Impairment; the second alleged a catastrophic impairment due to a Class 4 marked impairment. Adjudicator Bickley held that the claimant suffered a catastrophic impairment due to two Class 4 marked impairments, in social functioning and adaptation. She rejected the arguments regarding a 55 percent WPI, and held that the claimant’s injuries amounted to a maximum of 46 percent. In terms of the Class 4 marked impairments, Adjudicator Bickley preferred the evidence of the claimant’s experts due to the consistency and explanation in the report, and the expert’s consultation with the claimant’s family members. She also found that the surveillance tended to support the claimant’s submissions regarding social isolation and lack of independence. The claimed treatment plan was not awarded because it appeared to be proposed for the purpose of supporting the tort claim rather than the accident benefits claim.

Applicant v. Aviva Insurance Company (17-001007)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to two treatment plans for physical therapy. Adjudicator Watt held that the claimant’s injuries fell within the MIG and wrote that the claimant had not explained why her pre-existing obesity, hypertension, and sciatic nerve problems would prevent maximal recovery under the MIG. He favoured the opinions of the insurer’s assessors, and noted that the claimant had returned to work within five months of the accident. Adjudicator Watt also wrote that the proposed treatment plans were not reasonable and necessary because the description of the claimant’s injuries were inconsistent with the claimant’s actual injuries.

C.W. v. Unifund Assurance Company (16-003336)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision that the claimant’s injuries were non-minor due to a partial shoulder tear and pre-existing back pain. Executive Chair Lamoureux dismissed the reconsideration. She held that the Tribunal’s decision was based on the evidence before it and that the Tribunal was entitled to weight the contradicting evidence as it saw fit. Executive Chair Lamoureux was not satisfied that there was a significant error of fact or law.