A.R. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (17-000149)

The claimant sought entitlement to two proposed orthopaedic assessments. Adjudicator Msosa denied both assessments. He first wrote that without the treatment plans before him, he could not determine whether they were reasonable. He also accepted the opinion of the insurer’s expert that the claimant had not sustained orthopaedic injury in the accident and there was no medical or rehabilitative value to an orthopaedic assessment for the claimant’s soft tissue injuries.

Applicant v. Aviva Insurance Canada (16-003323)

The claimant sought entitlement to non-earner benefits, as well as a number of medical treatment plans. The insurer denied entitlement to all claims. Adjudicator Rebecca Hines reviewed the medical evidence and determined the claimant failed to prove the treatment plans were reasonable and necessary, and also failed to establish a complete inability to carry on a normal life. All of the claims were dismissed.

C.W. v. Unifund Assurance Company (16-003336)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision that the claimant’s injuries were non-minor due to a partial shoulder tear and pre-existing back pain. Executive Chair Lamoureux dismissed the reconsideration. She held that the Tribunal’s decision was based on the evidence before it and that the Tribunal was entitled to weight the contradicting evidence as it saw fit. Executive Chair Lamoureux was not satisfied that there was a significant error of fact or law.

Applicant v The Guarantee Company of North America (17-002558)

The applicant sought medical benefits for physiotherapy services. The respondent brought a motion to strike the applicant’s reply. The applicant filed a response to the motion to strike a day after the deadline. Adjudicator Goela held that despite being late, she would consider the applicant’s response as it did not prejudice the respondent. Adjudicator Goela further held that the applicant’s reply was struck because the applicant used the reply to introduce new information and arguments that should have been addressed in her initial submissions. The adjudicator also held that the applicant was also not entitled to the medical benefits sought as the treatment plans were related to injuries from a previous accident.

A.R. v. TD General Insurance Company (16-003487)

The claimant sought interest on re-instated IRBs and entitlement to an orthopaedic mattress. The insurer opposed paying interest, arguing that the claimant had not provided evidence earlier in her claim supporting IRB entitlement. Adjudicator Maedel held that once the insurer re-instated IRBs, the claimant was entitled to interest for the period IRBs had not been paid. He rejected the claim for a mattress because the claimant had not provided any explanation how the mattress related to her specific injuries, and had not provided the Tribunal with the treatment plan itself.

Applicant v. Traditional Mutual Insurance Company (17-002734)

The claimant sought entitlement to a psychological assessment. Adjudicator Norris held that the proposed assessment was reasonable and necessary. He relied upon the claimant’s consistency of reporting, prescription for antidepressants, and more than one medical practitioner opining that the claimant may suffer a psychological disorder.

Applicant v. Allstate Insurance Company (16-004309)

The claimant sought entitlement to ongoing NEBs and two proposed treatment plans for physiotherapy. Adjudicator Baker denied entitlement to NEBs but awarded the treatment plans. In terms of NEBs, Adjudicator Baker wrote that the claimant had submitted only limited evidence about his pre-accident and post-accident life, which did not support entitlement to NEBs. He also wrote that the activities set out in the insurer’s IE (as reported by the claimant) suggested that the claimant did not suffer a complete inability to live a normal life. In terms of the treatment plans, Adjudicator Baker held that further physical therapy was reasonable and necessary for the claimant’s soft tissue pain particularly given that it allowed the claimant to be more active in her day to day tasks.

Applicant v. RSA Insurance (17-000233)

The claimant disputed his entitlement to income replacement benefits (IRBs), medical benefits and the MIG. Adjudicator Treksler concluded that the claimant’s injuries fell outside of the MIG due a post-accident psychological impairment and diagnosis of chronic pain syndrome. In her reasons, Adjudicator Treksler noted that she preferred the evidence of the claimant’s family physician to the IE assessors and concluded that there was sufficient evidence in the claimant’s clinical notes and records of a psychological impairment and chronic pain syndrome to warrant the claimant’s removal from the MIG. Adjudicator Treksler also found that the disputed psychological assessment was payable. With respect to his dispute over IRBs, Adjudicator Treksler concluded that the claimant met the pre-104 week IRB disability test. Adjudicator Treksler noted that the claimant’s pre-accident employment was physical in nature and concluded that she preferred the s. 25 assessors’ conclusions that the claimant could not return to work to the opinions of the s. 44 assessors.

A.M. v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (16-003519)

The claimant sought entitlement to two treatment plans for dental work. Adjudicator Gosio rejected both claims. He held that the claimant had not submitted medical evidence in support of the claim (such as clinical notes and records, medical reports, or the treatment plans themselves) and that his counsel’s submissions were not evidence. Adjudicator Gosio also noted that the claimant’s dental pain appeared to have started four years prior to the motor vehicle accident.

C.R. v. Scottish & York Insurance Company (16-002077)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to one treatment plan. Adjudicator Anwar held that the claimant’s suffered pre-existing conditions that would prevent maximal recovery under the MIG and development of chronic pain. He relied upon the expert reports completed for the claimant, which detailed pre-existing injuries. The insurer argued that the Tribunal could not remove the claimant from the MIG without actually receiving and reviewing the clinical records from the claimant’s physician (which had not been provided to the insurer either). Adjudicator Anwar disagreed with the insurer, and wrote that the claimant’s experts had sufficiently detailed the pre-existing issues. He also noted that the insurer had not made any attempt to obtain the claimant’s clinical notes and records at any point (including the Case Conference). The adjudicator did not award the claimed treatment plan because the claimant did not explain what made the passive treatment reasonable and necessary, particularly given the claimant’s failure to respond to earlier passive treatment.