Applicant v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (16-004675)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to two treatment plans. Adjudicator Sewrattan concluded that the claimant suffered minor injuries in the accident. He wrote that neither of the claimant’s experts had diagnosed the claimant with a psychological disorder or chronic pain. He also held that the insurer’s denials satisfied the requirements of section 38 of the SABS. Adjudicator Sewrattan went on to state that he would not have awarded the claimed treatment plans because the claimant did not suffer a psychological disorder, and the treatment plan for chronic pain did not specify what the goals of the proposed treatment were.

Applicant v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-002689)

The claimant sought entitlement to a medical treatment plan. Adjudicator Derek Grant reviewed the medical evidence and noted that the mere submission of a treatment plan is not enough to establish entitlement. Rather, supporting medical documentation, recommending the treatment sought is critical. In this matter, the claimant failed to provide the necessary supporting evidence and as a result, the treatment plan was found not payable.

A.P. v. Dominion Insurance (17-001651)

The claimant sought entitlement to a treatment plan. The insurer denied payment and asserted a MIG designation. The claimant countered and argued the insurer failed to respond to the treatment plan within the prescribed time. Adjudicator Brian Norris reviewed the chronology of events and determined the insurer had responded to the treatment plan in time. Adjudicator Norris also determined that the claimant’s impairments were minor and that no pre-existing conditions warranted removal from the MIG. The claims were dismissed.

Applicant v. State Farm Insurance Company (16-004031)

The claimant sought entitlement to income replacement benefits as well as psychological treatment plans. The insurer denied IRBs and asserted the claimant’s inability to resume working was due to a pre-existing injury and not an MVA-related impairment. The psychological treatment was denied by the insurer as being not reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Deborah Neilson reviewed the medical evidence and noted that neither party tendered evidence from medical practitioners that addressed the claimant’s pre-existing conditions. Moreover, the claimant did not testify. Accordingly, it was held that the claimant failed to establish her impairments were directly as a result of the accident and prevented her from working. In the alternative, Adjudicator Neilson determined that the claimant failed to establish that she was substantially unable to resume working. As it pertained to the claim for psychological treatment, Adjudicator Neilson found that the treatment plan was necessary to address the claimant’s issues; however, based on the fees listed by the provider the plan was deemed unreasonable and therefore not payable.

Applicant v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (17-002337)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical benefits, as well as income replacement and attendant care benefits. The insurer denied entitlement and also asserted a MIG position. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson reviewed the medical evidence and determined that no compelling evidence was tendered by the claimant to support entitlement to any of the benefits claimed. The MIG was said to govern the claimant’s impairments and the matter dismissed.

Y.B. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-003257)

The claimant sought entitlement to two treatment plans. The insurer denied the plans and asserted neither was reasonable and necessary. The claimant also asserted that the IEs commissioned should have been paper reviews, and therefore not applicable to the insurer’s determination. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson, on review of the medical evidence, determined that neither treatment plan was reasonable and necessary. The assertion that a paper review IE should have been commissioned, rather than in-person examination, was also rejected.

B.T. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company(17-000086)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and costs of examinations. As a preliminary issue, the respondent argued that the claimant was barred from appealing her claims as she had not followed the procedures for claiming accident benefits under section 32 of the SABS. The claimant did not file a claim for accident benefits until July 2016, two and a half years after the subject accident. No explanation for the delay was provided. Adjudicator Ferguson concluded that the respondent was not required to pay the claimant’s claim for IRBs, as she did not comply with the prescribed procedures for claiming accident benefits. However, the amounts incurred with respect to the costs of examinations were payable pursuant to section 38(11). The claimant filed two assessment plans in June 2016 which the respondent did not deny.

S.B. v. State Farm Insurance (17-003290)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of medical benefits. On review, Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson determined that a number of treatment sought exceeded the monetary value claimed in the treatment plans, as well as in the Professional Service Guideline. Where the claims exceeded the PSGs, the treatment was not awarded. However, the remaining treatment plans, on review of the medical evidence were deemed reasonable and necessary.

T.T. v. Certas Direct Insurance Company (16-003055)

The claimant sought entitlement to IRBs and a number of treatment plans. Adjudicator Jeffrey Shapiro, on review of the medical evidence, as well as surveillance and employment records, noted that the claimant’s self-reporting was unreliable and had “failed to timely, honestly and accurately disclose his multiple actual returns to work and his ability to work.” As it pertained to the treatment plans sought, Adjudicator Shapiro concluded the claimant had failed to establish removal from the MIG was warranted. All claims were dismissed.

Applicant v. Aviva Insurance Canada (16-003997)

The claimant sought entitlement to treatment in the form of physical rehabilitation and acupuncture services. Adjudicator Cezary Paluch reviewed the medical evidence and determined that the injuries asserted by the claimant were as a result of the accident. On further review, the treatment sought was also deemed reasonable and necessary; the claims were found payable with applicable interest.