X.L. v. Unifund Assurance Company (17-008769)

The insurer sought the production of records from all post-accident physicians identified on the OHIP summary. The claimant did not dispute the relevance, but argued that the production of all records would be disproportionate. The Case Conference adjudicator did not make an order for such records, and the insurer sought reconsideration. Associate Chair Jovanovic ordered that the claimant produce the records from all of the physicians. He noted that the insurer had agreed to pay for the records, so there was very little prejudice to the claimant, and that to not provide the records to the insurer would be prejudicial to it.