L. Y. v Aviva Insurance Company (17-008847)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision, arguing that it had made a significant error of law or fact by referring to evidence not before it, placed the onus on the insurer, and failing to adhere to case law. On reconsideration, Adjudicator Norris held that he did not err in law in his decision. Adjudicator Norris held that he had reviewed the evidence and preferred the evidence of the claimant’s treating psychologist with respect to the reasonable cost of the proposed psychological assessment. Adjudicator Norris also held that the case law submitted by the insurer was unsupportive and therefore, did not apply.

P.Y. v Aviva General Insurance Company (17-003692)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision based on there being new evidence that the claimant could not have reasonably obtained earlier and based on the insurer’s concession at the close of the proceedings that the MIG did not apply. Adjudicator Grieves granted the claimant’s reconsideration request. Adjudicator Grieves accepted that the new evidence, being a s. 25 psychological report, was not reasonably available to the claimant at the time of the hearing and would have affected the Tribunal’s result with respect to its MIG finding. Adjudicator Grieves also criticized the parties for not advising the Tribunal that the insurer had agreed at the close of proceedings to remove the claimant from the MIG, as this would have affected the Tribunal’s result. Adjudicator Grieves ordered that the matter be sent back to the Tribunal to determine the reasonableness and necessity of the disputed treatments plans as the claimant was now out of the MIG.

S.H.S.K v. Allstate Canada (18-003699)

The claimant applied to the Tribunal disputing his entitlement to four treatment plans and interest. Of the four disputed treatment plans, the claimant disputed his entitlement to an orthopaedic assessment and MRI. Adjudicator Kaur concluded that the claimant did not prove that the orthopaedic assessment and MRI were reasonable and necessary as he failed to show how or why he could not obtain the assessment and MRI through OHIP. The claimant also disputed his entitlement to physiotherapy, which Adjudicator Kaur found was not reasonable and necessary, as the claimant did not provide evidence of a treating practitioner recommending this type of modality for his accident-related injuries. Finally, the claimant disputed his entitlement to a chronic pain assessment. Adjudicator Kaur noted that the claimant failed to provide any clinical notes and records that illustrated a history of ongoing pain complaints and that therefore, the proposed chronic pain assessment was not reasonable or necessary.

C.A. v. Intact Insurance Company (18-000579)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of the cost of catastrophic impairment assessments. Adjudicator Lester held that section 25(1)(5) only obligates an insurer to pay the reasonable fees charged in connection with filling out the application for the catastrophic determination rather than the assessments themselves. She also agreed that the reasonable and necessary standard applies to the determination of whether catastrophic impairment assessments would be payable by the insurer.

V.D. v. Unifund Assurance Company (17-005656)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s decision to reject her claims for a chronic pain program and a self-propelled lawn mower and snow blower. Adjudicator Paluch dismissed the reconsideration request. He concluded that the Tribunal had not misapprehended the evidence or erred in its legal analysis. The Tribunal was permitted to weigh the evidence as it saw fit, and to make a determination based on the weighing of evidence.

C.A. v. Intact Insurance Company (18-000579)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s denial of the cost of catastrophic impairment assessments. Adjudicator Lester held that section 25(1)(5) only obligates an insurer to pay the reasonable fees charged in connection with filling out the application for the catastrophic determination rather than the assessments themselves. She also agreed that the reasonable and necessary standard applies to the determination of whether catastrophic impairment assessments would be payable by the insurer.

G.L. v. TTC Insurance Company Limited (18-005322)

The claimant sought entitlement to five treatment plans. In addition to arguing that they treatment was reasonable and necessary, the claimant also argued that the insurer’s denials of three medical benefits did not comply with section 38(8) of the SABS. Adjudicator Grant found that the proposed treatment was not reasonable and necessary due to the lack of medical evidence. The claimant could not show that treatment was assisting him in any way or improving his functionality. Adjudicator Grant awarded the expenses related to two treatment plans which were not denied within the 10 day period required by section 38(8).

M.N. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-006097)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s refusal to re-open her application for entitlement to certain psychological services. The claimant and the insurer had agreed to resolve entitlement to proposed psychological services that were proposed. The services proposed were to be provided by a psychologist at the Guideline rates. The claimant then incurred the treatment with a psychotherapist, but at the psychologist rates. Vice Chair Shapiro concluded that the Tribunal was correct in refusing to re-open the original application. The nature of the dispute was not whether the claimant was entitled to the proposed services, but rather, whether the claimant incurred services that had been approved by the insurer and the proper rate of payment for the services the claimant incurred.

F.F. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (18-002994)

The claimant sought entitlement to medical marijuana and the cost of an assessment. Adjudicator Grant awarded both claims. He accepted that medical marijuana was a superior reliever of pain, anxiety and depression for the claimant, and that it was being recommended by the claimant’s family physician.

D.M. v. Aviva Insurance Canada (17-006781)

The insurer sought reconsideration of the Tribunal’s award of an orthopaedic assessment. Vice Chair Mather granted the reconsideration and denied the claimed assessment. She held that the Tribunal made a significant error of law in concluding that section 38(8) required a “clear and unequivocal” denial of the goods and services it was not agreeing to pay for. She held that the denial satisfied the requirements of section 38(8), and that the claimant failed to attend an IE. Vice Chair Mathers reviewed the submissions of the parties and held that the claimant failed to prove that the orthopaedic assessment was reasonable and necessary. She noted that the claimant had refused a similar referral from his family physician, and his medical imaging did not show any abnormalities. Further, the clinical notes and records did not support the existence of any orthopaedic injury.