Skip to the content
  • Areas of Practice
  • Mediation
  • Our Lawyers
  • News
  • Case Summaries
    • LAT Law Cases
    • Commercial/Tort Law Cases
  • Areas of Practice
  • Mediation
  • Our Lawyers
  • News
  • Case Summaries
    • LAT Law Cases
    • Commercial/Tort Law Cases

LAT Case Law Summaries

Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP is pleased to provide this online resource to our clients. Below is a searchable database of the publicly released decisions from the Licence Appeal Tribunal. Assembled by the accident benefits group, the decisions are reviewed, briefly summarized, and categorized for easy access.

As of March 2020, we will not include any further decisions focused solely on the Minor Injury Guideline or treatment plans, unless the case may have broader applicability.

August 25, 2017
/
tgp-admin

M.M. v. Echelon General Insurance Company (17-001456)

The insurer brought a motion to compel the claimant to produce tax returns. Adjudicator Robert Watt ordered the claimant to produce the requested productions as the parties appeared to agree that the order was necessary.
Read More
August 25, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant v. The Co-operators General Insurance Company (16-003564)

The claimant sought entitlement to one psychological treatment plan. The insurer denied the plan and cited the excessive progress report fees as one of the reasons the plan was not reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Lori Marzinotto evaluated the Ontario Psychological Association Guidelines for Assessment and Treatment in Insurance Claims and agreed that the treatment plan...
Read More
August 24, 2017
/
tgp-admin

P.J. v. Continental Casualty Insurance Company (16-004272)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of treatment plans. The insurer asserted a MIG defense. On review of the evidence, Adjudicator Nicole Treksler ruled the claimant's injuries, including chronic pain, were outside of the MIG. The treatment sought was deemed payable. The claimant also sought costs for the insurer failing to provide log notes...
Read More
August 24, 2017
/
tgp-admin

D.D.D. v. RBC Insurance Company (16-000097)

The claimant asked for reconsideration of the denial of IRBs. Executive Chair Lamoureux held that the adjudicator's factual findings were not subject to review, and that the evidence that the claimant had returned to work and was let off due to work shortages supported the conclusion that the claimant was not entitled to IRBs.
Read More
August 24, 2017
/
tgp-admin

D.D.D. v. RBC Insurance Company (16-000097)

The claimant asked for reconsideration of the denial of IRBs. Executive Chair Lamoureux held that the adjudicator's factual findings were not subject to review, and that the evidence that the claimant had returned to work and was let off due to work shortages supported the conclusion that the claimant was not entitled to IRBs.
Read More
August 23, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant (By his Litigation Guardian) v. State Farm Insurance (16-001691)

The insurer denied payment of IRBs following the 104 week period. The claimant brought an application before the LAT; however, the insurer asserted a limitation position. Adjudicator D. Gregory Flude reviewed the chronology of events and noted the claimant's steadily declined in condition and eventual need for a court appointed litigation guardian. Nevertheless, no explanation...
Read More
August 22, 2017
/
tgp-admin

S.S. v. Aviva General Insurance (17-001183)

The claimant sought entitlement to two treatment plans. The insurer denied the plans and cited insurer's examination reports as justification. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson reviewed the medical reports on both sides and noted contradictions in the claimant's self-reporting. Additionally, one of the treatment plans sought was not included as evidence. The insurer's evidence was considered more...
Read More
August 22, 2017
/
tgp-admin

M.Z. v. Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance (16-002126)

The claimant sought entitlement to three medical benefits, including a vocational assessment. She was not employed at the time of the accident. Adjudicator Anwar awarded all three medical benefits on the basis of medical evidence showing potential lumbar spine injuries. He also awarded the vocational assessment reasoning that it was appropriate for the claimant to...
Read More
August 18, 2017
/
tgp-admin

N.K. v. Unica Insurance Inc. (17-001473)

The claimant sought removal from the MIG and entitlement to medical benefits. Adjudicator Ferguson held that the claimant suffered a concussion and post-concussion syndrome, which were not minor injuries. The claimant was therefore removed from the MIG. The sought medical benefits were denied because the claimant and his treatment providers had not explained how the...
Read More
August 18, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant v. Aviva General Insurance (17-001178)

The claimant sought entitlement to a psychological treatment plan. The insurer denied the treatment plan and cited a psychological insurer's examination report as justification. Adjudicator Christopher Ferguson reviewed the medical reports on both sides and noted contradictions in the claimant's self-reporting. The insurer's evidence was considered more credible and the treatment plan was deemed not...
Read More
August 17, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Y.X.Y. v. The Personal Insurance Company (16-000438)

The primary issue in dispute was whether the claimant sustained a predominantly minor injury as a result of the accident. Adjudicator Neilsen explained that ongoing pain alone was insufficient to remove the claimant from the "minor injury" definition. Rather, she had to prove chronic pain syndrome. The ongoing pain had to be accompanied by some...
Read More
August 17, 2017
/
tgp-admin

T.S. v. Aviva General Insurance (17-000835)

The primary issue in dispute was whether the claimant sustained a predominantly minor injury as a result of the accident. Adjudicator Ferguson rejected the claimant's allegations of psychological injury. He also rejected the submission that the claimant's chronic pain was not covered by the definition of "minor injury." Adjudicator Ferguson accepted that the claimant did...
Read More
August 16, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Chen v. Unifund Assurance Company (17-001476)

A catastrophically injured minor sought entitlement to the insurer's log notes as part of the preliminary issues, arguing that the insurer's denials were insufficient to explain why claimed benefits were denied. The insurer argued that the log notes were not relevant and that the claimant was engaged in a "fishing expedition." Adjudicator White ordered the...
Read More
August 16, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant v. Jevco Insurance Company (16-002000)

The claimant was involved in a serious accident and had sustained ongoing physical, psychological, and cognitive impairments. He had returned to doing some work on a part-time basis, but was unable to engage in full time work or retraining. Adjudicator Truong held that the claimant was entitled to post 104-week IRBs based on a holistic...
Read More
August 14, 2017
/
tgp-admin

D.T. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (16-000266)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal's decision to deny medical benefits above MIG limits and IRBs. The Tribunal had denied the claimant's entitlement to these benefits based on its review of the available medical evidence. The claimant made multiple arguments: first, that the Tribunal did not consider evidence indicating she suffered from a pre-existing...
Read More
August 14, 2017
/
tgp-admin

C.L. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance (16-002085)

The claimant sought entitlement to a number of treatment plans. The insurer asserted the plans were not reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Derek Grant determined the injuries complained of by the claimant were as a result of the accident; however, on review of the medical evidence, the treatment plans were deemed not reasonable and necessary.
Read More
August 14, 2017
/
tgp-admin

D.T. v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company (16-000266)

The claimant sought reconsideration of the Tribunal's decision to deny medical benefits above MIG limits and IRBs. The Tribunal had denied the claimant's entitlement to these benefits based on its review of the available medical evidence. The claimant made multiple arguments: first, that the Tribunal did not consider evidence indicating she suffered from a pre-existing...
Read More
August 11, 2017
/
tgp-admin

L.K. v. The Guarantee Company of North America (16-003577)

The claimant's entitlement to income replacement benefits had been suspended for about six months due to her failure to provide a copy of her CPP file, which had been requested by the insurer under section 33 of the SABS. Upon receipt of the CPP, the insurer reinstated income replacement benefits, but refused to pay for...
Read More
August 11, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant v. Security National Insurance Company (16-003024)

The claimant sought entitlement to medical benefits and removal from the MIG. He also argued that the insurer's denials did not comply with section 38 of the SABS. Adjudicator Belanger-Hardy dismissed the claims. She held that the insurer's denials provided sufficient information to comply with the SABS. She also held that the evidence submitted supported...
Read More
August 10, 2017
/
tgp-admin

R.R. v. Aviva Insurance (16-001627)

The claimant sought entitlement to treatment plans requesting assistive devices and psychological treatment. The insurer denied the plans as not being reasonable and necessary. Adjudicator Chris Sewrattan reviewed the medical evidence and determined that the claimant did not provide sufficient evidence to show the devices were reasonable. However, the psychological treatment was considered payable. No...
Read More
August 9, 2017
/
tgp-admin

Applicant v. Yarmouth Mutual Fire (17-001057)

The minor claimant sought entitlement to medical benefits and mileage. Adjudicator Ferguson dismissed all claims. He held that proposed social worker services were duplicative of approved treatment; further the claimant was completing self-care and school tasks as expected for someone of his age. In terms of OT services, the claimant did not explain what in-home...
Read More
Page 1 … Page 100 Page 101 Page 102 Page 103 Page 104 … Page 113

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1800

416.507.1850

eodonnell@tgplawyers.com

  • Areas of Practice
  • Mediation
  • Our Lawyers
  • News
  • Case Summaries
  • Careers

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1800

416.507.1850

eodonnell@tgplawyers.com

© 2020 Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Statement of Principles

Powered by Crow & Pitcher

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1800

416.507.1850

eodonnell@tgplawyers.com