Commercial/Tort Case Law Summaries

Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP is pleased to provide this online resource to our clients. Below is a searchable database of key cases impacting the defence of commercial and tort litigation. Assembled by Sarah Jones, Natasha O'Toole, and Chris Schnarr, each case is reviewed, briefly summarized, and categorized for easy access.

Search

Generic filters

June 13, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Knox v. Loblaws Inc., 2018 ONSC 3679

In denying the Plaintiffs' motion to discontinue the action as against certain defendants, the court commented on the distinction between the effect of a discontinuance and a dismissal of an action. Pursuant to the Rules of Civil Procedure, the discontinuance of all or part of an action is not a defence to a subsequent action,...

June 13, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Coast Capital Equipment Finance Ltd. v. Old Republic, 2018 ONCA 540

This appeal dealt with whether the lessor, Coast Capital, was insured for third party liability. 62254641 Canada Inc., a trucking company, leased a tractor from a third party. Old Republic issued a Certificate of Automobile Insurance which listed that vehicle. The Certificate included a description of lessors which stated "as per OPCF 5 Forms". An...

June 5, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Enterprise Rent-A-Car v. Intact Insurance, 2018 ONSC 3517

On appeal, Enterprise argued that the applications judge erred in finding that the driver of the rental car (a listed driver under her father's OAP1) was not "an insured named in the contract" and/or a "driver named in the contract" such that the priority provisions of s. 277(1.1)(2) of the Insurance Act would apply. The...

May 16, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Walsh v. Papadopoulos, 2018 ONSC 1828

Summary judgment is not likely to be granted if the motions judge has any doubt as to whether a defendant can be found even 1% liable on the available evidence and case law. In this case, the plaintiff and defendant sisters were transporting items into the home of the defendant sister's boyfriend. The plaintiff fell...

May 11, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Rankin (Rankin's Garage & Sales) v. J.J., 2018 SCC 19

The minor Plaintiffs entered an unsecured garage property and stole a vehicle. The vehicle was subsequently involved in an accident and Plaintiff J suffered a catastrophic brain injury. At trial, it was found that the garage owed a duty of care to J. This finding was upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal. However, the...

May 10, 2018

/

tgp-admin

National Art Gallery v. Lafleur de la Capitale Inc., 2018 ONSC 2921

A janitor had a fatal slip and fall incident in the course of his work at a gallery. The deceased employee's family members commenced actions against the gallery for damages. The gallery commenced third party claims against the janitorial company. The gallery was an additional insured on the janitorial company's CGL policy and argued that...

May 7, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Mega International Commercial Bank (Canada) v. Yung, 2018 ONCA 429

Section 18(1) of the Limitations Act, 2002, states that there is two years from the date of service of the pleading to make a claim for contribution and indemnity. In this case, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that discoverability applies to section 18(1) and that the Act did not create an absolute limitation period...

April 13, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Turcotte v. Lewis, 2018 ONCA 359

The Defendant tavern had a bus service that picked up, and later dropped off, cottage country patrons. On the return voyage, an argument broke out and the security guard on the bus called the police and asked for the police to meet the bus at the drop-off spot. When the bus arrived at the drop-off...

April 13, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Wallbridge v. Brunning, 2018 ONCA 363

In this case, a lawyer, Brunning, allegedly defamed another lawyer, Wallbridge. Brunning was practicing "in association" with the Williams law firm. The Williams firm brought a summary judgment motion to dismiss the claim, on the basis that it was not vicariously liable for Brunning's alleged defamation. The motion court granted the motion. On appeal, the...

April 10, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Lapierre v. Lecuyer, 2018 ONSC 1540

In this case, the Plaintiffs were all Family Law Act claimants. Their claims related to the death of an individual who died in a motor vehicle accident in Ontario. The deceased had been a resident of Quebec, as was the Defendant. Three of the FLA claimants were residents of Quebec and three were residents of...

April 4, 2018

/

tgp-admin

A.B. v. Waite, 2018 ONSC 2151

The jury awarded the Plaintiff $42,250.00 for pain and suffering which was reduced to $4,266.67. Justice MacLeod also awarded 4% interest because of the delay in the trial occurring. The jury awarded $76,121.00 for past income loss which was reduced to $0 after deductions for accident benefits and LTD benefits were considered. Justice MacLeod noted...

April 4, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Tomson et al v. Jackson et al, 2018 ONSC 2155

The Defendants in a motor vehicle accident action sought production of the examination for discovery transcript from the Plaintiff's action against her LTD provider. The injuries relating to her LTD claim arose from the same motor vehicle accident. Master Fortier held that the transcript was relevant and ordered that it be produced at the Defendants'...

March 29, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Handley Estate v. DTE Industries Limited, 2018 ONCA 324

The Plaintiff entered into litigation agreements with the Defendant, H&M Combustion Services Ltd., relating to an oil spill. In the 2011 agreement, H&M agreed to defend the action and commence a third party claim, which the Plaintiff would fund. In the 2016 agreement, H&M assigned all of its interest in the lawsuit to the Plaintiff,...

March 28, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Schnarr v. Blue Mountain Resorts Limited, 2018 ONCA 313

In Schnarr v. Blue Mountain and Woodhouse v. Snow Valley Resorts, the Plaintiffs executed the ski resorts' waivers of liability as a condition of the purchase of their lift tickets and were subsequently injured. In Schnarr, the motion judge held that the resort could not disclaim liability for any breach of the deemed warranty of...

March 26, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Rososhansky v. Williams, 2018 ONSC 1964

The Plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle accident. He produced several medical reports which indicated that he sustained head and neck injuries as a result of the accident. At the pre-trial, despite not yet conducting a medical examination of the Plaintiff, the Defendants took the position that there was "zero chance" of financial liability...

March 21, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Grieves v. Parsons, 2018 ONSC 1905

The jury found that the Plaintiff was entitled to $61,000.00 for past loss of income and $90,000.00 for future loss of income/loss of competitive advantage. Six months before the trial, the Defendants made a Rule 49 offer of $70,000.00, inclusive of all claims and PJI, plus partial indemnity fees up to the date of the...

March 20, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Balasingham v. Desjardins Financial Security, 2018 ONSC 1792

The Defendant requested an adjournment of the trial because of the late delivery of expert reports by the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff opposed the adjournment request. Justice Firestone refused the Defendant's request for an adjournment of the trial, but ordered that the Defendant was entitled to a defence medical examination of the Plaintiff and could deliver...

March 9, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Lipovetsky v. Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada, 2018 ONSC 1649

Prior to examinations for discovery, the Defendant listed three surveillance douments, including the date, author, and recipient, in Schedule "B" of its Affidavit of Documents. The Plaintiff took the position that additional particulars were required including the form of the document, the timing of surveillance sessions, and the number of pages of any report. Master...

March 9, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Douglas v. Stan Fergusson Fuels Ltd., 2018 ONCA 192

The Ontario Court of Appeal unanimously held that the Plaintiff's insurer was not entitled to commence a subrogated claim in the name of its bankrupt insureds. In this case, at the time the action was commenced, the insureds' cause of action had vested in the trustee in bankruptcy and one of the insureds was an...

March 7, 2018

/

tgp-admin

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company v. Cronnox Inc., 2018 ONSC 1578

The insured engineering company had two different insurers over two policy periods. Both policies were "claims made and reported" policies. A fire occurred on a project in which the insured was involved. During the first policy period, the insured received correspondence warning of intention to commence a claim against it and inviting the engineering company's...

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1850

smilne@tgplawyers.com

© 2020 Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Statement of Principles

Powered by Crow & Pitcher

Subscribe to get TGP’s case summaries straight to your inbox

Subscribe to get TGP’s case summaries straight to your inbox

Contact Us

150 York Street, Suite 1800
Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S5

416.507.1850

smilne@tgplawyers.com

© 2020 Thomas Gold Pettingill LLP